My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more!
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 23, 2021
1:00
:15
pm
Diablo and Doc
All-American
Been talking about this for years. The BYU talent level and depth is below
average. Wilson and a weak schedule last season created the illusion that BYU was back.
When it comes to hiring assistants, the ability to recruit talent comes first.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Diablo and Doc
Previous username
Ruby Soho
Bio page
Diablo and Doc
Joined
Oct 26, 2005
Last login
Jun 29, 2024
Total posts
15,806 (867 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
My thoughts on Tuiaki before you guys start calling for his job later today. Fan bases have made huge mistakes
HarlemCoug
Free to change my mind
10/23/21 11:50am
Good post. Reasoned and analytically supported.
CLCougar
10/23/21 11:54am
Baylor exposed us for the talent gap
Jericho
10/23/21 11:56am
Been talking about this for years. The BYU talent level and depth is below
Diablo and Doc
10/23/21 1:00pm
We need to upgrade coaches as well. There is no excuse for keeping walk on
kotacoug
10/23/21 1:07pm
Hmmm… how many teams without P5 money and without P5 recruiting advantages have
NYC and Japan
10/24/21 12:18am
This is 100% true. We need to upgrade coaching & talent or the result at Baylor
BlooCoog
10/23/21 1:19pm
So did USF, CC, AZ booze, toledp, waot....you said coaching ability gap
CarolinaCoug
10/23/21 10:51pm
100%
SingleStrapBackpack
10/23/21 11:59am
Or how about just learn best practices, the scheme and play calling combo
PortlandCoug
10/23/21 12:00pm
You could argue the exact opposite as well. Easy to cherry pick an example like
CougGolf
10/23/21 12:02pm
Assistants aren’t the same here though. Usually on 1-2 years deals at BYU.
Turnpike Lane
10/23/21 12:05pm
Well thought out. I'd offer a few points of rebuttal
gaspasscoug
10/23/21 12:06pm
One additional counter. We already have a better DC on the staff. Kalani Sitake.
cougaman
10/23/21 12:22pm
Nailed it.
kotacoug
10/23/21 12:38pm
Great points
TNT
10/23/21 1:06pm
My question that will never get answered:
CaliWG
10/23/21 1:07pm
Good points. However, it is clear we have coaching and scheme issues on defense.
kansascougar
10/23/21 12:07pm
He's had 6 years to improve the DL, which is the position he coached..
Coug
10/23/21 12:08pm
This is the issue. Tuiaki can’t claim a lack of talent
Kilgruman
10/23/21 12:23pm
Amen Brother
BYU313
10/23/21 12:09pm
RE: My thoughts on Tuiaki before you guys start calling for his job later today.
BigHouse Coug
10/23/21 12:11pm
6. First 6 games. Defense was not the issue vs Boise
BYU313
10/23/21 12:15pm
Defense failed to respond in the second half.
BigHouse Coug
10/23/21 12:28pm
Personally I dont buy that
BYU313
10/23/21 1:01pm
RE: My thoughts on Tuiaki before you guys start calling for his job later today.
mudpupper
10/23/21 12:16pm
It’s not about the secondary playing ‘man’ it’s about what the DLs and LBs are
kotacoug
10/23/21 12:18pm
Amen
TNT
10/23/21 1:11pm
I trust Kalani.
Robbinoburrito
10/23/21 12:23pm
I'm glad bronco wasn't hesitant to replace hill
Deleted
10/23/21 12:25pm
You replace him w/ a guy who understands how to teach proper tackling technique.
byubyu
10/23/21 12:26pm
I've heard complaints about byu's tackling for 30 years.
GSwarriorcoug
10/23/21 12:30pm
Hmmm so another "there's no one better" argument. Nice.
byubyu
10/23/21 12:31pm
We are 5-2 - if you think we have more missed tackles than
GSwarriorcoug
10/23/21 12:35pm
What was byus record detmers first year? How close to indefezted? Your logoc
CarolinaCoug
10/24/21 2:06pm
You obviously aren't following my logic.
GSwarriorcoug
10/24/21 2:38pm
Tell me more about this. What tackling method is Tuiaki teaching? What are the different tackling methods taught at
HarlemCoug
10/23/21 12:44pm
You tell me. You have all the non answers of "there's no one better".
byubyu
10/23/21 12:53pm
Offering PRE-rebuttals to criticisms of your DC might mean you have a bad DC
GeraldGarner
10/23/21 12:27pm
And the argument of ‘we can’t find anyone better’ is rather lame as well.
kotacoug
10/23/21 12:31pm
No one in the country will ever want to be a dc in the big 12 without a mormon requirement even
Deleted
10/23/21 12:40pm
Don't understand all of the enthusiastic Tuiaki supporters
BigHouse Coug
10/23/21 12:44pm
Not supporters, we are defenders. All we are saying is we could do worse.
Cougzilla
10/23/21 1:00pm
Fair enough but I also believe we can do better, and probably should.
BigHouse Coug
10/23/21 1:06pm
Lol, ok. So a “Tuiaki hater” is just someone who thinks we could do better.
GeraldGarner
10/23/21 1:18pm
Fair enough, we are also saying he is not that bad.
Cougzilla
10/23/21 3:35pm
I’ve been called a racist by a board member because of my critique of Tuiaki…
kotacoug
10/23/21 1:09pm
Hmm, that makes me wonder if it goes both ways for criticism and support.
BigHouse Coug
10/23/21 1:15pm
Some fans are like that with all BYU coaches. It's kinda weird
TNT
10/23/21 1:17pm
Counterpoints: 1) we should be recruiting better by now and 2) there are better
runnincoug
10/23/21 12:43pm
The only reason I think it might be a good idea is because I admittedly know
downtownchrisbrown
10/23/21 1:08pm
lol
CougtheCreator
10/23/21 1:57pm
Sorry Harlem… already aging poorly.
Ned Schneebly
10/23/21 1:58pm
Lots to play, but defense has played pretty well since first drive...
CLCougar
10/23/21 2:36pm
Still don’t get it, do you.
Horacio Caine
10/23/21 2:44pm
Same could be said for you on several levels
CLCougar
10/23/21 2:51pm
I’m summary he still needs to go
dizthewiz
10/23/21 2:57pm
Defense sure hasn't been the problem this game as much as you'd wish it was
CLCougar
10/23/21 3:06pm
Offensive play calling has been atrocious.
dizthewiz
10/23/21 3:15pm
Uh.. That was my point in challenging your narrative against the D this game bro
CLCougar
10/23/21 3:18pm
I got the point but the D is still bad bro
dizthewiz
10/23/21 3:41pm
RE: My thoughts on Tuiaki before you guys start calling for his job later today.
Falco
10/23/21 2:58pm
We appreciate your input, Sister Tuiaki.
tjngirlz
10/23/21 3:45pm
I don’t agree with him on this point but Harlem is a good poster.
Ned Schneebly
10/23/21 5:00pm
I've gotten acquainted with him and he's an awesome and generous dude. Very successful in career. Need more like him..
CLCougar
10/23/21 5:08pm
I roll my eyes at those who have rolled their eyes. This post is solid
OldFogey
10/23/21 7:15pm
Football is for entertainment and pleasure. His style of defense is not enterta
gilmerbuckeye
10/23/21 10:46pm
Talent is obviously not the issue. We have talented players. Idk what needs to
thechillcougar
10/24/21 9:49am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad