NO, that's a terrible breakdown. In fact, it's not a "breakdown" of any kind.

Report problem with this ad

Sep 27, 2021
2:51:18pm

kccougar Intervention Needed

That usually involves a discussion of WHY something happens, not simply a regurgitation of the end result.

Report problem with this ad

kccougar

Bio page: kccougar
Joined: May 29, 2001
Last login: Jun 29, 2024
Total posts: 89,195 (15,213 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I’m shocked at how many likes this post has. What an eye roll by the OP.

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 1:51pm

So to be clear, your criticism of Tuiaki's defense is how much he publicly berates his players?

kccougar

9/27/21 1:55pm

But getting in people’s faces isn’t what makes Saban great.Its the wins & losses

CougSilver

9/27/21 1:56pm

… which come as a result of him not settling for just winning.

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 1:59pm

And what have you observed to be Tuiaki's approach when interacting with his players?

kccougar

9/27/21 2:00pm

What inside info do you have that Tuiaki doesn't hold his players accountable?

sidsie716

9/27/21 2:04pm

You and kccougar are really stuck on that part, which isn’t even the point.

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 2:19pm

"More often than not" that's just simply not close to true. That was a poor

Blueto

9/27/21 2:38pm

And you are stuck on the second half of USF representing this whole season.

sidsie716

9/27/21 2:42pm

I am? This is a chronic criticism of Tuiaki.

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 4:09pm

Arizona and ASU were well called games.

sidsie716

9/27/21 4:15pm

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder I guess. Most disagree with you.

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 4:37pm

Polls here from after those games would say otherwise

sidsie716

9/27/21 5:16pm

This is exactly the problem with your critique. It's false. I want you to do

Blueto

9/27/21 4:46pm

Holy pick and chose… ugh.

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 4:49pm

It's the one example you used. If you want discussion on something else, give us more.

kccougar

9/27/21 2:49pm

And the talent.

CougSilver

9/27/21 2:06pm

What’s the old sports adage? Something like “you cannot win on talent alone”…

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 2:15pm

Tuiaki sucked on Saturday, plain and simple. I'm sure injuries, young players,

Sock Gnome

9/27/21 1:59pm

"Tuiaki sucked on Saturday" - I'd love for you to break that down for us.

HONOMO

9/27/21 2:05pm

"We rested injured starters" is not a good breakdown, but good try. We played a

Sock Gnome

9/27/21 2:12pm

And if they play like they did against Arizona, ASU, and Utah we will be fine

sidsie716

9/27/21 2:14pm

I'm not choosing anything as a representative sample except in saying that this

Sock Gnome

9/27/21 2:16pm

The most current example with half of our starters out on D. Won't be the case

HONOMO

9/27/21 2:19pm

I'm asking you to break it down b/c you're the one saying Tuiaki sucked.

HONOMO

9/27/21 2:17pm

No stops in the second half isn't a good breakdown? It's a heck of a better...

Sock Gnome

9/27/21 2:21pm

He sucks because he sucks isn't really a breakdown.

SoCalCoug

9/27/21 2:36pm

Ok see you at the game!

HONOMO

9/27/21 2:38pm

NO, that's a terrible breakdown. In fact, it's not a "breakdown" of any kind.

kccougar

9/27/21 2:51pm

How about Florida A&M playing USF almost as tough as BYU on defense

BYU '80

9/27/21 2:13pm

USF's previous QB is not as good.

kccougar

9/27/21 3:09pm

First half was fine, even good at most points.

sidsie716

9/27/21 2:06pm

Byu doesnt create enough negative plays to get off the field.

BYU '80

9/27/21 2:14pm

They got off the field very well against Arizona and Utah

sidsie716

9/27/21 2:20pm

They created a lot of negative plays against those teams with asu helping with

BYU '80

9/27/21 2:26pm

Right, and I would never argue they looked good second half against USF

sidsie716

9/27/21 2:33pm

It wasn’t the 2nd half of the game though. Starting in Q2 USF moved the ball

Ned Schneebly

9/27/21 2:28pm

Would argue some of that, but regardless, my main point still stands

sidsie716

9/27/21 2:34pm

Did he really?

kccougar

9/27/21 2:23pm

Also Alden Tofa and George Udo got their first snaps of the season.

Blueto

9/27/21 2:40pm

Lol. Lots of coaches get in their players faces and suck. Nick Saban is great

Blueto

9/27/21 2:09pm

I think he also stated that "Many of those games were won by the defense.

HONOMO

9/27/21 2:13pm

Our coaches agree with this post

stansburycoug

9/27/21 2:18pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad