My brother and I were talking about cars. Specifically we were talking about Paul Walker dying in a Porsche Carrera GT. I mentioned that I had never seen the GT except for on Jay Leno's Garage. And then I turn and say, "isn't that a Carrera GT?!" as a car passes us. And my brother says, "and that's Jay Leno driving." Completely bizarro.
The other one was a friend at a sports bar in Spokane says, "isn't that Samuel L Jackson sitting at the table next to us?" There were hardly any customers in there. It was lunch and we were watching the 2006 World Cup. I slowly turn... and... there is Samuel L Jackson in a houndstooth suit and matching fedora... in Spokane. Not expected!