My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Feb 19, 2020
6:00
:51
pm
ldssdl
All-American
Zach may yet turn out to be the best QB of the 3, but you're not proven right
yet when Zach put up 6 points against NIU, 21 points against Toledo, and 3 points against SDSU.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
ldssdl
Bio page
ldssdl
Joined
Mar 3, 2013
Last login
Sep 20, 2024
Total posts
30,326 (3,960 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Zach is the best QB on the roster — objective analysis reveals this
Gotnotact
2/19/20 3:48pm
Again? Man...let's wait until fall camp.
Preppy
2/19/20 3:49pm
Yes. Again. And I'll post as much as I want. Especially when I'm right.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 3:53pm
RE: Yes. Again. And I'll post as much as I want. Especially when I'm right.
Preppy
2/19/20 3:59pm
I agree with you. 100%. I went and watched the Boise game again
BYURider
2/19/20 5:56pm
Zach may yet turn out to be the best QB of the 3, but you're not proven right
ldssdl
2/19/20 6:00pm
okay, can you tip us off when you plan to post about something that you're right
icecougar
2/19/20 7:20pm
We'll see in spring ball. Glad there is competition. All 3 deserve it.
Turnpike Lane
2/19/20 3:50pm
Totally agree.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 3:51pm
There is no competition. The staff already promised it to zach and his family
indocoug
2/19/20 4:11pm
Not anymore.
Mathew
2/19/20 4:13pm
Lip service/coach speak so guys won't transfer is all it was
indocoug
2/19/20 4:14pm
precisely my fear
icecougar
2/19/20 7:21pm
Was that before year one?
ColonelMustard
2/19/20 10:00pm
Hopefully there will be a real competition and not the coaches
dodgersjazzcougs
2/20/20 1:55pm
give it up. you already posted this morning....
idacoug
2/19/20 3:53pm
That was last night.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 3:54pm
You've convinced us....you certainly were up in the night.
StarMan
2/19/20 4:03pm
People are interested in what I have to say.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:39pm
I think we're more interested to see how long you're going to keep trolling this topic
Wingnut
2/19/20 4:41pm
I think people are interested in disagreeing with you.
pilot17
2/19/20 4:41pm
And they click.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:47pm
Oh brother...he was the worst of the three last year and struggles agonist G5
Dangerous
2/19/20 3:53pm
He'll be named the starter by the end of Spring Camp. Even at the end of 2019...
Gotnotact
2/19/20 3:56pm
Reason for that: Romney and Hall were injured
ataylor
2/19/20 6:22pm
Not for the Hawaii Bowl
Rat
2/19/20 7:14pm
For the Hawaii Bowl:
ataylor
2/19/20 7:26pm
Sure, but it stills proves my point since they were cleared to play.
Rat
2/19/20 9:37pm
Big difference between being cleared to play and being considered healthy enough
ataylor
2/19/20 9:59pm
BYU has 3 very average and interchangeable D1 QBs.
Backcountry
2/19/20 3:54pm
Hopefully someone will emerge. The returning stats from receivers are concerning
Gotnotact
2/19/20 3:56pm
Good QBs cover that weakness pretty well
puntersarepeople
2/19/20 3:59pm
He was the best QB for Utah that's for sure.
byubyu
2/19/20 3:55pm
He had the best performance against Utah of any BYU QB in a decade
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:00pm
I've got a 5' tall tool box with almost "all the tools imaginable, but it
Mountain Rat
2/19/20 5:46pm
I think the skill throws show his talent
puntersarepeople
2/19/20 3:57pm
He was bad against UW and Toledo before the injury.
Dangerous
2/19/20 3:57pm
Offensive line was Swiss cheese vs UW. ZW actually started strong
puntersarepeople
2/19/20 4:01pm
I think that's a fair point...
icecougar
2/20/20 11:57am
The thing with Wilson is that he has a bright future IMO if he can figure out
puntersarepeople
2/20/20 12:55pm
RE: Zach is the best QB on the roster — objective analysis reveals this
USMCdad
2/19/20 3:57pm
At least be transparent. Feel you’re one of these 3:
Soupie
2/19/20 3:58pm
None. Never met him or his mom.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:01pm
Shame, she’s pretty cool
USMCdad
2/19/20 4:04pm
I'm no QB coach, but there was a comfort I felt with Romney under center that I
hxmCougar2000
2/19/20 4:00pm
Because he was going against easier teams
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:01pm
Wasn't Boise State ranked at #14 when he played against them?
Wingnut
2/19/20 4:03pm
Paper tiger
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:06pm
So what would you call NIU, Toledo, SDSU, and Hawaii then?
ldssdl
2/19/20 4:18pm
Clearly the next 4 in when the P5 expands
USMCdad
2/19/20 4:19pm
Did BYU really play anyone who was great? Weren't they all paper tigers or paper
ochobeeguy
2/19/20 4:21pm
Hmm, I think Zach played during some of the ugly losses against "easy teams"
Preppy
2/19/20 4:05pm
This is also true. He's got work to do.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:38pm
bingo
BYURider
2/19/20 5:58pm
Romney is a better decision-maker, Zach has more physical gifts
inertiaman
2/19/20 4:15pm
This might be true.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:16pm
There is so much you don't know. You should try harder to be on certain FO's.
Mathew
2/19/20 4:04pm
Like the ones you and your cool friends are on?
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:15pm
You finally got-it-no-tact
Mathew
2/19/20 4:18pm
Sounds like you've got a lot of friends.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:39pm
One or two
Mathew
2/19/20 4:47pm
At this point, your posts are doing more to provoke criticism of each of the
gwalker
2/19/20 4:08pm
He’s not looking to be positive at all for BYU, he’s clearly trolling
USMCdad
2/19/20 4:10pm
Lifelong fan. Incredibly positive advocate of BYU. Just a realist.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:23pm
When it comes to Zach, it doesn't sound like you're a realist
Mountain Rat
2/19/20 5:51pm
We get it. A 14 year fan.
ochobeeguy
2/19/20 7:52pm
^This
ColonelMustard
2/19/20 9:04pm
I wish him the best
BYU Fan
2/19/20 4:14pm
What is your relation to Zach?
conetah
2/19/20 4:20pm
A valid question.
ochobeeguy
2/19/20 4:21pm
None. Zero. I've seen him in person twice, against Utah and USC.
Gotnotact
2/19/20 4:27pm
Where's the objective analysis part of the post?
fldnstrm
2/19/20 5:10pm
He might be. But his play last year has allowed the door of competition to justifiably be reopened.
SpiffCoug
2/19/20 5:55pm
That’s fair
Gotnotact
2/19/20 6:33pm
Agreed! Signed Zach's Mom
icecougar
2/19/20 6:18pm
Dude you’ve got to stop. You are embarrassing yourself and your friend Zach
ColonelMustard
2/19/20 6:19pm
Na
Gotnotact
2/20/20 12:18am
PS Boardname checks out
ColonelMustard
2/19/20 6:21pm
If our QBs were cars....
Pretorian
2/19/20 6:59pm
RE: Zach is the best QB on the roster — objective analysis reveals this
icecougar
2/19/20 7:07pm
Offense sucks anyway, Defense has been the saving grace
XwhyZ
2/19/20 7:19pm
WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON
Michael McQuain
2/19/20 7:27pm
RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON
ataylor
2/19/20 7:30pm
RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON
ataylor
2/19/20 7:34pm
RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON
ataylor
2/19/20 7:36pm
RE: WELCOME TO MY IGNORE LIST MR. WILSON
ataylor
2/19/20 7:37pm
Okay, I’m done
ataylor
2/19/20 7:38pm
RE: Okay, I’m done
Cru Jones
2/19/20 9:10pm
RE: Okay, I’m done
Cru Jones
2/19/20 9:10pm
RE: Okay, I’m done
Cru Jones
2/19/20 9:10pm
RE: Okay, I’m done
Cru Jones
2/19/20 9:11pm
RE: Okay, I’m done
Cru Jones
2/19/20 9:12pm
Zach had Ty'Son and didn't do well. Baylor had Katoa and Finau and won a huge
Ash
2/19/20 7:37pm
2-2 against the meat of the schedule isn't doing well?
puntersarepeople
2/19/20 8:25pm
LOL, are you honestly comparing Finau to Ty'Son?
Ash
2/19/20 10:17pm
No. But I think there was a huge drop off without Finau as there was without
puntersarepeople
2/20/20 10:43am
Romney's worse game was better than ZW best game in 2019. Drop the mic 🎤
blackshirts
2/19/20 8:35pm
stats are more helpful in context
puntersarepeople
2/19/20 8:43pm
Simple, QBR
blackshirts
2/19/20 8:52pm
Zach Wilson is NOT undoubtedly the best QB on BYU's roster
CaliforniaCougar22
2/19/20 9:31pm
Yes he is
Gotnotact
2/20/20 12:23am
I’m not really sure how “objective” that analysis is.
CoachSpeak
2/19/20 11:19pm
There is nothing in your post that’s objective, at all.
akmewg
2/19/20 11:30pm
Will someone please agree with gotnotact so he can
coastcat
2/20/20 6:50am
Subjective reality reveals you don't know what objective reality is.
canofpicante
2/20/20 9:02am
Two examples (from source) of INTs not ZW's fault.
TailgateU
2/20/20 9:36am
The first one the wr fell down...
CoachSpeak
2/20/20 9:39am
Still went through his hands. A receiver needs to catch that ball.
TailgateU
2/20/20 9:58am
And Zach needs to make a better throw...
CoachSpeak
2/20/20 10:23am
The receiver must catch that.
Gotnotact
2/24/20 11:50am
That's a nice slogan
shakarocks
2/24/20 11:58am
And Zach must throw a better ball...
CoachSpeak
2/24/20 12:04pm
It was a crap throw high and behind the receiver.
shakarocks
2/20/20 10:39am
Who cares?
shakarocks
2/20/20 10:11am
not to mention the many dropped INTs that DBs could / should have caught
mcnasty
2/20/20 12:45pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad