I know the cool thing to do these days is hate on Eli, but come on.
2x super bowl champion
2x super bowl MVP
1 of only 5 players to have multiple super bowl MVPs (Brady, Starr, Montana, Bradshaw)
Top 10 all time in passing yards
Top 10 all time in touchdowns
Top 10 in game winning 4th quarter drives
2nd longest streak of consecutive starts in NFL history.
This isn't even an argument.