My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 12, 2018
6:20
:53
pm
Jdoc
Walk-on
I agree he was the most talented, but he couldn’t stay on the fields save his
one amazing year. If he could stay healthy, I would take him.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Jdoc
Bio page
Jdoc
Joined
Feb 8, 2018
Last login
Sep 28, 2024
Total posts
11,130 (19 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Harvey Unga vs. Jamaal Williams vs. Luke Staley
prcoug
8/12/18 2:29pm
Luke, and it’s not really close.
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:30pm
Reasoning? Seemed wonder how others would do with Luke's o-line?
prcoug
8/12/18 2:31pm
A healthy Luke was head and shoulders better.
Metallicat
8/12/18 2:35pm
Speed, power, size, catching ability
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:39pm
He’s conflicted.
pt crasher
8/12/18 4:05pm
He had one great year. One. Jamaal and Harvey had better
Jdoc
8/12/18 2:38pm
*because of injury
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:39pm
Agreed, but I don’t think you can say he was the
Jdoc
8/12/18 2:41pm
The question was who would I like to see
conflictedcoug
8/12/18 2:45pm
RE: He had one great year. One. Jamaal and Harvey had better
Northern Blue
8/12/18 4:49pm
I agree he was the most talented, but he couldn’t stay on the fields save his
Jdoc
8/12/18 6:20pm
That's why I specified, Junior Year Luke Staley
WhiteKnight
8/12/18 6:43pm
Luke without a second thought
WhiteKnight
8/12/18 2:32pm
But he wasn’t healthy. You can’t play the what if game.
Jdoc
8/12/18 2:34pm
Ok, Doak Walker Trophy 2001. There's an accomplishment for you.
dreamlvr
8/12/18 3:21pm
And, I might add, it was very well deserved. He was the best back in the whole
dreamlvr
8/12/18 3:24pm
Years? He was healthy one year. Listen, I would take
Jdoc
8/12/18 3:25pm
That a guy with that much talent had such terrible knees and ankles was the
dreamlvr
8/12/18 3:33pm
It really is unfortunate. He was an amazing talent.
Jdoc
8/12/18 3:36pm
Jamaal. He played against much tougher opponents than Luke ever did.
Richbyu
8/12/18 2:35pm
Plus he shared the backfield with Taysom.
BYihateU
8/12/18 3:10pm
I don't think there's a wrong choice between Jamaal and Luke. I'd take either before Harvey.
SpiffCoug
8/12/18 2:43pm
Harvey was amazing strength and speed/ shiftiness. Would have the record
claw
8/12/18 2:45pm
JW>LS>HU.
Holy Driver
8/12/18 2:52pm
Tough decision. Give me any of them... They were all very good by BYU standards
Jericho
8/12/18 3:05pm
Assuming the injuries, off the field issues, etc all remained: H > L > J
Wedgetail
8/12/18 3:39pm
Luke, no question
zerome4sooners
8/12/18 3:42pm
Luke Staley was incredible.
Heath Squashwell
8/12/18 3:44pm
Luke was great but the chance of him finishing a season would be nearly zero
HighHorse
8/12/18 4:06pm
Harvey was a threat for a good gain each play
Dan
8/12/18 4:22pm
I'd go with Jamaal. So consistent. Staley was amazing, but that was just one yr.
sportsbro
8/12/18 4:48pm
Love all. I'd go Luke, Unga & Williams. Jamaal is the only one to play 4 years.
Benfica1
8/12/18 4:52pm
Jamaal, Luke, Unga
D.T. Survivor
8/12/18 6:34pm
Harvey...4 year Harvey.
Kama'aina
8/12/18 6:42pm
I wish we could have seen 1 more year for HU, he was unstoppable
pegushin
8/12/18 7:31pm
You could make a good case for any one of the 3
CougarsFanSince80s
8/12/18 7:30pm
Agree on being able to make a case for any of them
D.T. Survivor
8/12/18 8:28pm
To anyone who actually watched Luke Staley play, this is an easy question.
Ham
8/12/18 9:08pm
I watched Staley play and based on Jamaal’s sr year, I give him the edge
D.T. Survivor
8/12/18 9:18pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad