Or, ya know, if they're just not as good.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jun 14, 2018
1:05:56pm

Lip Gallagher All-American

Or, ya know, if they're just not as good.

It appears you haven't listened to nearly every other post in the thread. No coach in the world would go purely on seniority. And being seasoned does not at all mean you're good.

Coaches would love for it to work out that way, but there's nothing close to a guarantee right now.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Jun 14, 2018 at 1:05:56pm

Message modified by Lip Gallagher on Jun 14, 2018 at 1:08:12pm

Report problem with this ad

Lip Gallagher

Previous username: Rusty'sJuicyCknHole
New username: Chef Carl Casper
Bio page: Lip Gallagher
Joined: Apr 26, 2013
Last login: Apr 30, 2022
Total posts: 0 (0 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Why start Freshman QB if he is slightly better than rest?

playbook

6/14/18 9:46am

With the new redshirt rules, you may see 3-4 QBs get significant time this year

2FarGone

6/14/18 9:50am

Some guys transfer when they see the best guy isn’t starting

mosterlow

6/14/18 9:50am

When 4 QB are very close and all have different strengths. Choosing a starter ca

playbook

6/14/18 11:24am

Can be very subjective?

playbook

6/14/18 11:25am

It's not rocket science. You play to win. You play for now. You play who gives

6/14/18 9:51am

Agree. Upside needs to be set aside when deciding who plays/who will win today.

BluebloodOR

6/14/18 11:17am

I have a hard time believing Tanner isn't the best of the group.

Mister P

6/14/18 10:00am

Is he even throwing yet?

mosterlow

6/14/18 10:08am

Wasn’t he throwing in Spring ball?

2FarGone

6/14/18 10:16am

Oh I didn’t think he took any reps in spring ball

mosterlow

6/14/18 10:41am

If that is the case, we are in trouble. Did you watch him when he was

Dangerous

6/14/18 10:10am

Taysom didn't look good in that system either, until the 2nd half when Ty would

fulano

6/14/18 10:19am

The Detmer years cannot be used for reference on the QBs. It was that messed up.

mudpupper

6/14/18 11:22am

Define better. I think too many CBers weight potential too heavily. You play the

OneUpper

6/14/18 10:14am

I think is pretty safe to say there is no big separation at this time

Pretorian

6/14/18 11:47am

Which means there's no guarantee on any QB from fr. to sr.

6/14/18 1:07pm

In boxing Wilson would have to knock out the incumbents

playbook

6/14/18 3:35pm

Kalani needs to get to 6-6 to save his job.

displacedute

6/14/18 11:11am

Very solid post, I like your logic

Pretorian

6/14/18 11:44am

I don't think it's good. What does it say to recruits or potential young transf.

6/14/18 1:53pm

pointless discussion. Mangum, Hoge, Critchlow are all more seasoned than

Jericho

6/14/18 11:45am

Or, ya know, if they're just not as good.

6/14/18 1:05pm

Mangum will start and Hoge will back him up

Jericho

6/14/18 1:31pm

When your only argument against a kid is that he hasn't played in a game yet,

6/14/18 1:41pm

I’m not making an argument against anyone

Jericho

6/14/18 1:58pm

The argument itself was merely that they were seasoned.

6/14/18 2:04pm

Seasoned counts for something, but I agree that it will only take you so far

Jericho

6/14/18 3:25pm

RE: Why start Freshman QB if he is slightly better than rest?

longtimeYfan

6/14/18 3:32pm

Mission first kid

playbook

6/14/18 6:10pm

The big difference between Lavell situation and today's situation...

hammergm

6/14/18 7:05pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad