My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
May 26, 2018
11:44
:55
pm
billyrust
All-American
Hard to judge. Had he stayed healthy and played a standard schedule
He’d be top ten for sure.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
billyrust
Bio page
billyrust
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Last login
Dec 30, 2019
Total posts
20,964 (1,157 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Taysom Hill. Top ten BYU QB?
Holy Driver
5/26/18 11:33pm
Nope.
Gerald-DeGroot
5/26/18 11:33pm
Don’t know. But I think he’s the best athlete to ever don the Y
Future_Tacos
5/26/18 11:36pm
I don't know about that
shakarocks
5/26/18 11:45pm
Hard to argue with your logic.
Future_Tacos
5/26/18 11:47pm
Don’t forget people like Ziggy Ansah
BYUCLA
5/27/18 11:29am
Pure athleticism....yes....and no one else is close....
Bonoman
5/26/18 11:51pm
Young was just as athletic if not more
PenrynCoug
5/26/18 11:55pm
Young was never the strongest lifter pound for pound like Taysom was in college and is in the NFL...
Bonoman
5/27/18 12:01am
young was a better athlete
PenrynCoug
5/27/18 12:04am
Even Young himself said Taysom was a better Athlete.
cougsrule
5/27/18 12:08am
Because he was slower and weaker?
ZooBlue
5/28/18 5:22pm
That's because Young really didn't lift a lot
shakarocks
5/27/18 12:06am
Just because you can list a lot doesn't mean you are a great athlete.
BlueForLife
5/27/18 11:54pm
You completely leave out coordination
shakarocks
5/27/18 12:09am
That’s right, Taysom can’t throw at all or play basketball or do anything else...all he can do is lift and run fast..SMH
Bonoman
5/27/18 12:34am
He didn't say that. He's basically saying Steve Young is more coordinated
Yunit
5/27/18 3:21pm
He actually struggled with throwing to a degree
shakarocks
5/27/18 9:29pm
No. Steve Young
Little Britches
5/27/18 11:50am
Carter and sheide were really good too
midlandcoug
5/26/18 11:38pm
Overlooked imo.
Heinz57
5/26/18 11:43pm
I'd put Virgil Carter in the top 10 ahead of Doman and Hill.
ptcougr
5/27/18 3:03am
Agree with this. History needs to be put in perspective. Top 10 yes.
coastcat
5/27/18 9:17am
Hard to judge. Had he stayed healthy and played a standard schedule
billyrust
5/26/18 11:44pm
Yes.
Dr MoBYU
5/27/18 8:19am
Drop Doman for Hill and you’re good.
Ned Schneebly
5/27/18 8:19am
This article has a good list
Bucko
5/27/18 9:28am
Top ten talent, not top ten performance.
rockhound
5/27/18 5:36pm
How I feel too
Little Britches
5/27/18 9:00pm
I love Hill, but he is not a top ten. Never really had a great full year, never even beat Utah, no post season success
nybyblue
5/27/18 7:36pm
How about Gifford Nielson, he also started on bball team as freshman
baldcoug74
5/27/18 9:58pm
Not sure I would use "beating Utah" as a measuring stick.
Eddie
5/27/18 11:21pm
Very true. Even when Gifford was QB we were beating Utah consistently.
Holy Driver
5/28/18 6:27am
If Taysom makes it in the NFL as some are now anticipating, he will be remembered differently.
mvtoro
5/28/18 2:57am
Hill>>Fetrrick or Walsh
Reedme
5/28/18 7:18am
Taysom is at the top of the "what if" list. He could have challenged for the
Fdnman
5/28/18 8:31am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad