Sorry but BYU would not have been better last year with Luke over Jamaal. Jamaal's style was exactly what that supporting cast needed. He needed the outside game and BYU's weak spot was on the outside. And blockers that were hit or miss. And no passing game to help. Jamaal has had to play in 3 different systems and excelled in all of them. Luke was probably as "system" of a guy as we could get from what we've seen. And he was so great at that style, and got to play in it, he just blew it away and it wasn't close. It would have at least been nice to see that team play tougher defenses.