My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 21, 2016
2:03
:56
am
Shteve
Walk-on
Agreed. Which is why if something isn't working
You makes changes, even if the move is solely to prepare you for the future. More live game reps now will only help tanner and this offense going forward. It's simple emergent strategy.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Shteve
Bio page
Shteve
Joined
Apr 17, 2015
Last login
Apr 21, 2018
Total posts
1,840 (16 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Do you guys even remember the Michigan game? The Mizzou game? The SJSU game?
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:32am
Sad we'll never be able to find out
franklyvulgar
10/21/16 1:33am
Where's he going next year?
SoCalCoug
10/21/16 1:38am
<< Deleted >>
Abe Froman
10/21/16 10:56am
This argument has been made a million times. Tanner was a freshman, Taysom is
crazY
10/21/16 1:34am
And you field the best player for 2016. That's taysom, like it or not.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:35am
How do you know?
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:37am
The same way you do.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:37am
I know what you are but what am I
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:38am
What are you seeing that the coaches aren't?
SoCalCoug
10/21/16 1:39am
4th and 19
thebruce
10/21/16 11:20am
how do you know? look, I have hoped they put in Tanner but I don't work with the
fattycoug
10/21/16 1:39am
RE: And you field the best player for 2016. That's taysom, like it or not.
crazY
10/21/16 1:38am
That's what the coaches believe. They see tanner practice every week.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:42am
YOU SHOUDLNT CARE WHAT HE DOES IN PRACTICE
Shteve
10/21/16 1:45am
Name a D1 program that pulled their starter after a 1 point loss to a top 15
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:46am
or show where the majority of the teams that replace their QB midseason are
fattycoug
10/21/16 1:48am
Both very bad ideas as far as coming to conclusions off of them.
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 1:57am
Agreed. Which is why if something isn't working
Shteve
10/21/16 2:03am
Joe Montana 1977 National Championship Team
Shteve
10/21/16 2:01am
majority
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:03am
what good does playing Taysom have for this program?
Shteve
10/21/16 2:07am
You should ask that at Monday's coordinator's corner.
SCcoug
10/21/16 2:10am
if it's so obviously the wrong call to play taysom. then you have to say the
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:12am
Yes it appears many in this thread are saying just that.
SCcoug
10/21/16 2:14am
some are also saying that they aren't replacing him because they are afraid
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:15am
I shouldn't be on here after losses. Too many emotional knuckleheads.
SCcoug
10/21/16 2:16am
Wait, what? To question decisions of coaches is to call them outright idiots?
marklar39
10/21/16 2:34am
Now that you mention it. How do explain Fake punt from own endzone 4th and 19???
Osteotome
10/21/16 10:49am
Ty Detmer comes to mind.
crazY
10/21/16 2:05am
correct me if I am wrong, and I could very well be, but didn't he come in becaus
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:13am
You're correct. Bad memory on my part.
crazY
10/21/16 2:16am
Name a D1 team this year whose defense provided them 5 TOs
Shteve
10/21/16 2:09am
Only 3 of those to's resulted in the offense coming on the field. So 1 of 3.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 2:10am
Fair point. With a blocked field goal and return to near mid field
Shteve
10/21/16 2:17am
LOL, and plz remind us all how much Taysom had to do with being that close? lol
Ash
10/21/16 11:12am
I honestly believe Tanner gets sacked 8+ times, and throws at least one INT
Dissenter
10/22/16 1:22am
??? Based on . . . ? Tea leaves? Because we haven't seen him in this offense.
Michicoug
10/22/16 7:51am
I thought Taysom was a 5th year senior. First game of college career was 2012. No previous redshirt other than the medic
MacGyver
10/21/16 10:27am
If only there were some way to prove he could play well against Boise...
Disco LaFleur
10/21/16 1:35am
17-28, 309 yards, 2 TD/2 INT.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:38am
Cool, calm, and collected in the end.
Disco LaFleur
10/21/16 1:39am
And a W. In his second game ever.
bluesloth
10/21/16 1:39am
21-42, 187 yards, 0 TD/0 INT
crazY
10/21/16 1:42am
Taysom also ran for a TD.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:43am
1 inch dives ftw
franklyvulgar
10/21/16 1:44am
Because the 30 yard strike to MJ came up 1/2 yard short.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:45am
You're squarely for Taysom at quarterback. Fine. That's cool. But when things
Disco LaFleur
10/21/16 1:53am
Tanner still had twice as many points as Taysom did.
crazY
10/21/16 1:47am
He also had Houk, Matthews, and Blackmon.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:49am
Yet none of them had touchdowns that game. Juergens had both touchdowns.
crazY
10/21/16 1:54am
Right.
flyusaf
10/21/16 3:15am
So what's your argument?
crazY
10/21/16 8:59am
Better receivers in 2015.
flyusaf
10/21/16 9:51am
Better qb too
thebruce
10/21/16 9:59am
Yet 3 of the top 6 receivers are back.
crazY
10/21/16 10:14am
And let's be real, Jonah Trinnaman is as good as blackmon
thebruce
10/21/16 10:20am
Remember he was limited that game. Hamstring injury
Orange4Life
10/21/16 6:21am
I'd take that with our run game in a heartbeat.
macaroni
10/21/16 7:47am
So Taysom isn't at fault because the problem is the team but Tanner is fully
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:36am
Didn't say that.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:38am
No. It's a team game. Blame goes around.
SCcoug
10/21/16 1:38am
Exactly.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:39am
The player who touches the ball every play can significantly affect the game.
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:39am
You're right. Cougarrrs is wrong. I love Taysom, but he's dropped hard...
marklar39
10/21/16 1:40am
My problem is that when an offense consistently lacks production, the answer in MOST cases at most schools is to
ChinaFan
10/21/16 1:41am
Problem is they haven't lacked until today. Against a top 15 team at their place
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 2:15am
You must have been watching a different BYU then than the rest of us -
OGSuperfan
10/21/16 2:21am
Right Taysom's been terrific against everyone else which is why the passing
Michicoug
10/21/16 7:43am
Agreed. He was thrown into the fire and struggled often, in a very different
BigD Coug
10/21/16 1:41am
Don't forget Tanners post-mish rust and hamstring injury
Run-DMT
10/21/16 1:44am
Yeah he played well given the situation he was in.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:46am
He's the best freshman QB BYU has EVER had
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:47am
You just can't really say that. Everyone has got to stop using
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 1:45am
We shouldn't use the only evidence we have? That would be weird.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:48am
He is literally the best freshman QB ever at BYU. Of course he will improve in a
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:49am
Uh... Remember when Jake Heaps was literally the best freshman qb BYU ever had?
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 9:33am
Jake Heaps was not the best freshman QB BYU has ever had. Tanner holds records.
crazY
10/21/16 9:49am
The records that Heaps had before Tanner broke them you mean?
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 3:40pm
Also not arguing that Tanner isn't/won't progress or that he should or shouldn't
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 3:44pm
Heaps did do well for a freshman. But Tanner came in and obliterated Heaps' records.
indocoug
10/21/16 11:13am
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 3:39pm
We shouldn't assume that players stay exactly the same year after year.
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 1:53am
No, we analyze it in CONTEXT.
macaroni
10/21/16 7:49am
Our offense in the past two games put up 14 and 13 points, respectively. 14 and 13! Our d scored more last night! And
macaroni
10/21/16 7:54am
No but MAYBE he would IMPROVE with reps for NEXT year. Taysom ISN'T IMPROVING
Osteotome
10/21/16 10:55am
It's weird, you and I agree on almost everything these days
thebruce
10/21/16 10:32am
I don't think we ever disagreed on a ton of stuff.
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 2:10pm
You just literally listed the #2, 3, and 6 ranked pass Ds in college football
thebruce
10/21/16 4:15am
Uconn and Utah state both had top 18 pass D last year.
thebruce
10/21/16 4:17am
Starting Tanner could have been about 2017 not just 2016
Cougstreak
10/21/16 5:23am
The fact that they didn't pull Taysom in this game pretty much guarantees
jensen46
10/21/16 6:18am
Because Tanner would obviously be exactly the same as last year and have not
Michicoug
10/21/16 7:39am
I think your memory is poor.
macaroni
10/21/16 7:47am
How so?
flyusaf
10/21/16 9:53am
TRUE FRESHMAN JUST OFF HIS MISSION. Yes I'm yelling. This is nearly the
TheLoneCougar
10/21/16 8:08am
Do you guys realize Tanner was passing to Matthews, Blackmon & Houk?
cougar_chick1
10/21/16 8:42am
AND had no Jamaal.
Michicoug
10/21/16 8:49am
When you have crap receivers trying to catch from a crappy QB the problem is
thebruce
10/21/16 8:51am
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Excellent Points
Osteotome
10/21/16 10:59am
The underlying assumption here is that Tanner is exactly the same as he was
Frank Castiglione
10/21/16 9:40am
Taysom taking the sack with 22 seconds left was probably the toughest thing to see.
indocoug
10/21/16 10:19am
He pulled the ball down to run but ran right into the teeth of the awaiting D
Osteotome
10/21/16 11:00am
PREACH
doctorthunderpants
10/21/16 10:24am
RE: Do you guys even remember the Michigan game? The Mizzou game? The SJSU game?
HowardH
10/21/16 11:04am
Who was his RB last year?
Ash
10/21/16 11:08am
8 yard Carter
thebruce
10/21/16 11:17am
Somehow he managed to get 37 carries lol
thebruce
10/21/16 11:19am
He trailed in the 2nd half to UConn and Cincy....
jsjohnson1278
10/21/16 12:28pm
Top 25 pass defenses last year.. go look
CarolinaCoug
10/22/16 9:13am
RE: Do you guys even remember the Michigan game? The Mizzou game? The SJSU game?
Bullrider
10/21/16 1:19pm
The backup QB is always the most popular player on the team.
Wear Blue
10/22/16 11:22am
Only on teams with a QB not getting it done
thebruce
10/22/16 11:29am
You're a hopeless coachbot.
Ash
10/22/16 11:32am
And you are hopeless.
Wear Blue
10/23/16 1:59am
We are 4-4 with awful QB play.
Shteve
10/22/16 11:39am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad