http://www.nfl.com/draft/history/fulldraft?abbr=U&collegeName=Utah+State&abbrFlag=0&type=school
Do your homework, if they'll go play for a nobody program in the middle of nowhere and surrounded by a largely LDS population, they'll jump at the offer from BYU. Talented kids that would play for BYU are out there, just got to find them and offer them. Guys like Mike Davis and Akile Davis come right to mind. Offer more of those type of guys.
Also, do you really believe that the BYU players not of the LDS faith are living the HC for 4-5 years? Please, don't be so naive.