Maybe the types of athletes the NFL is using these days just doesn't line up perfectly with the type of athlete BYU is traditionally recruiting?
I actually don't think recruiting has been that bad. Bronco has had some good classes and some bad one, but overall I would not say that recruiting is his big weakness.
Also, if his recruiting has been so poor, why haven't our teams been much worse? How can we even manage to win any football games if we have essentially no talent on the team?