impossible to be wrong. No one said there were no similarities between their resumes, just that one is better-developed and impressive on its face than the other.
Outside of the similarities you pointed out, Sitake has several years before he got to Utah as a college coach, and he has a few years as a DC since his promotion at Utah, as well as his experience as a DI football player, all of which you seem to be pretending are irrelevant. The fact that Sitake is "further along," as you said, isn't a throwaway, it's the whole point.
But yeah, if you compare a four-year period of their resumes, there are some striking similarities.