Felix just needed a couple more good years but he imploded.

Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Jan 6, 2025
12:58:30pm

shimmy triples are best

Felix just needed a couple more good years but he imploded.

Report problem with this ad

shimmy

Previous username: AFCoug83
Bio page: shimmy
Joined: Jan 15, 2008
Last login: Jan 8, 2025
Total posts: 123,468 (38,125 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Based on the first ~100 HoF ballots, Ichiro, CC Sabathia, Billy Wagner, and Carlos Beltran are all above the 75% line.

TCuz Coastal Elite

Jan 6, 12:44pm

Sad to see Ian Kinsler's hall of fame dreams are over.

russkiejedi

Jan 6, 12:48pm

CC as a first ballot HOF is wild to me. I'm here to argue the yankees bump

shimmy

Jan 6, 12:49pm

I can only assume that’s why Ichiro is getting 100% too, but it will be fun to see two players get elected

TCuz

Jan 6, 12:54pm

He's being rewarded for endurance and for being on some really good teams.

Zooropa

Jan 6, 12:58pm

Will the Mariners join the Yankees with two 99%+ HOFers while no other team has

Jan 6, 12:52pm

Ichiro had more at-bats in the playoffs as a New York Yankee, so he counts for them too. 3-1.

TCuz

Jan 6, 12:55pm

If anyone doesn't vote for Ichiro, their rights should be rescinded.

Zooropa

Jan 6, 12:54pm

Felix just needed a couple more good years but he imploded.

shimmy

Jan 6, 12:58pm

Felix had 50 bWAR through his age 29 season and was as much of a HoF slam dunk as you can be at that age

TCuz

Jan 6, 1:00pm

I think it's defensible to say a corner OF with a career 107 OPS+ shouldn't be

Scratch

Jan 6, 1:11pm

I think the only reason to not vote for a HOFer should be if you don't have any votes left. Waiting to vote

shimmy

Jan 6, 1:16pm

I kind of like the idea of unanimity being reserved for the very most elite.

Scratch

Jan 6, 1:23pm

I would be there with you if it wasn't such a cudgel in the past because Babe wasn't elected. Like how was Willy Mays

shimmy

Jan 6, 1:32pm

Wait CC Sabathia is a first ballot HOFer?

kimdaddy35

Jan 6, 1:05pm

As a TBS Braves fan kid I loved Andruw Jones. I hope he makes it.

pinolero

Jan 6, 1:16pm

Carlos Beltran should take a hit for being the mastermind of the Astros scandal

troutmaster13

Jan 6, 1:22pm

Like I said above, I think it’s worse than steroids and yet looks like he’ll ultimately get elected

TCuz

Jan 6, 1:32pm

I disagree with it being worse then steroids

troutmaster13

Jan 6, 1:40pm

Is that THE a-rod?

BaseCoug

Jan 6, 1:31pm

You can tell, because he's one of the few people named Alex who put the accent

russkiejedi

Jan 6, 1:53pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad