I think the point is that there are ways to assess the quality of an offense that is more nuanced

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 24, 2024
3:43:31pm

GoodBetterBestBYU Walk-on

I think the point is that there are ways to assess the quality of an offense that is more nuanced

Like on base percentage in baseball is a better measure for some needs. BYU’s offense is solid and getting better. Won 10 games second year. Have no idea why people are so nuts about the offense and want to fire the OC. Kim daddy is pointing out that we were much better than the frustrating few plays that: a) every team has, and b) it’s important to realize byu relative to all programs.

Report problem with this ad

GoodBetterBestBYU

Previous username: goodbbetterbestBYU
Bio page: GoodBetterBestBYU
Joined: Oct 23, 2024
Last login: Dec 25, 2024
Total posts: 995 (3 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Two things we desperately need to upgrade are OC and DL. Looks like

Kale

Dec 24, 9:55am

You’re wrong about the OC. I’ve posted on this before at length.

macdizzle

Dec 24, 9:58am

Heard the same thing with Tuiaki. If he were good he would have other job offers

Kale

Dec 24, 10:01am

You most definitely did not hear that on Tuiaki. He was below 100 in those metrics.

kimdaddy35

Dec 24, 10:05am

You heard Tuiak's D was consistently top 35?

Crazy Joe Davola

Dec 24, 10:05am

How do you know he hasn’t?

Zombre

Dec 24, 10:05am

OC did this in B12 year 2. Pretty good performance.

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 10:14am

Haha what?

chitownboy

Dec 24, 10:52am

Can you at least hope he cuts down the number of ludicrous play calls?

shammy

Dec 24, 10:02am

You think a different OC won’t make ludicrous play calls?

StantonMac

Dec 24, 10:14am

Maybe. But the keyboard warriors blind to the possibilities for improvement

shammy

Dec 24, 10:26am

I agree with you. He just needs to eliminate the ridiculous plays that don’t

Dec 24, 10:32am

Wow. You're right. ARod is the best OC that has ever lived. He can't improve.

shammy

Dec 24, 10:38am

Whoa. Chillax. Meds.

Benfica1

Dec 24, 10:43am

Easy there speed racer. You're kinda spazzing out. Go check your brisket, muppet

shammy

Dec 24, 10:46am

😬

Benfica1

Dec 24, 10:52am

Did you leave it in too long?

shammy

Dec 24, 10:55am

I haven't seen someone so unhinged since joining CB.

Benfica1

Dec 24, 11:02am

Nice Christmas Eve back and forth fellow cougars…

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 5:11pm

super easy to see needs to improve. What most on here don't understand is the process for improvement doesn't usually

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 10:34am

You don't fire people after a season like this one. But you can try to improve.

shammy

Dec 24, 10:39am

Somebody should tell the coaching staff to try and improve at their jobs.

Dec 24, 10:44am

You argued that they can't improve, with your facetious post. Which way is it?

shammy

Dec 24, 10:48am

I think that's what they try to do all the time. Many take a bad play and conclude coaches aren't trying to improve

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 10:53am

Let’s all hope that he makes perfect play calls every game. All 60+ of them bends to be perfect

TADOW

Dec 24, 10:47am

Ignore him. He's been saying the same crap for years. Nothing pleases him.

Benfica1

Dec 24, 10:02am

I think Hill has done a great job

Kale

Dec 24, 10:56am

10 wins 2nd year in B12 where offense had to bail out defense as well. Team play.

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 11:02am

Agree.

Benfica1

Dec 24, 11:03am

Does the PPG include TDs by the D and special teams? Bc they sure scored a lot.

SwampyCoug

Dec 24, 10:09am

No, not in points per drive offensive metric. Any other questions that you clearly don't

kimdaddy35

Dec 24, 10:12am

I asked about PPG, not points per drive. And don't know why you're so defensive.

SwampyCoug

Dec 24, 10:52am

Hard for him to defend a losing position.

LOLzzz

Dec 24, 11:17am

Defense and special teams took huge steps forward. Just want the O to do same.

SwampyCoug

Dec 24, 11:24am

How many points of data would you like? FEI? F+? Wins and losses?

kimdaddy35

Dec 24, 4:59pm

So you responded to a post about ppd and asked how he does with a completely different stat?

kimdaddy35

Dec 24, 3:06pm

Seriously? Let me quote exactly what I responded to: "Both Points per Drive and

SwampyCoug

Dec 24, 3:27pm

I think the point is that there are ways to assess the quality of an offense that is more nuanced

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 3:43pm

No defense for kimdaddy. He was wrong and caustic. Odd mix. But I understand the

SwampyCoug

Dec 24, 4:03pm

Team wins and team losses

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 4:17pm

True. And hopefully it'll keep getting better.

SwampyCoug

Dec 24, 4:24pm

Amazing progress in one year. Lots of positivity around offseason recruiting too

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 4:28pm

After watching the 4 playoff games, ARod is better Han at least 4 of the OCs in those games

Littlerich

Dec 24, 10:13am

Those are both paper stats this season. I ve posted at length about ST, Def pts

stansburycoug

Dec 24, 10:32am

I think the biggest thing ARod can improve upon is cadence of the offense. To often this year, we slowed things down

specsauce

Dec 24, 10:41am

Your 2nd point and the untimeliness of certain plays is 100% it

stansburycoug

Dec 24, 10:52am

What is wrong with the OC? BYU's offense took a big positive leap from last year

darkcoug

Dec 24, 9:59am

Maybe poor play call 1st and 5 for

BYU71

Dec 24, 10:08am

Your posts make me laugh.

kimdaddy35

Dec 24, 3:09pm

I think we need to upgrade some of our fans.

cougaman

Dec 24, 10:00am

Let's hit the transfer portal. Maybe Nebraska, Baylor, KSU fans? Which others would we go after?

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 10:16am

There’s a few Ute fans that need to see the light and hit the transfer portal.

cougaman

Dec 24, 10:27am

How about Notre Dame fans – they travel? I'd take Ole Miss fans. WSU fans?

Benfica1

Dec 24, 10:28am

Notre Dame would be solid. Nope on USC, UCLA, Cal, Stanford. I like Boise State because I grew up there but others don't

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 10:35am

Utah is desperate. We are not.

niqmadu

Dec 24, 10:03am

We're 10-2. I propose we start firing some fans.

HarlemCoug

Dec 24, 10:05am

Oh Kale, I admire your tenacity, but you don't fire people after a 10-2 season.

JC6

Dec 24, 10:23am

Speaking of Kale –

Benfica1

Dec 24, 10:32am

You at least do what the defensive side of the ball did and

interpolagent

Dec 24, 11:51am

I didn't even notice the boardname until now. What does it rhyme with?

GoodBetterBestBYU

Dec 24, 10:36am

I was reminded of one of my favorite memes. It's about kale.

HarlemCoug

Dec 24, 11:54am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad