A lot of success is circumstantial.

Report problem with this ad

Dec 9, 2024
7:16:16pm

whoneedscorners? All-American

Report problem with this ad

whoneedscorners?

Bio page: whoneedscorners?
Joined: Oct 2, 2005
Last login: Jan 7, 2025
Total posts: 30,725 (1,534 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Isaac Wilson has been downgraded

mjmill All-American

12/9/24 7:03pm

That should have happened the day he signed to play QB at Utah

CougarCanuck76

12/9/24 7:04pm

Hillstead has proven more at the FBS level, TBD who will end up being better.

Junior Deputy

12/9/24 7:04pm

From what I’ve seen of Hillstead during fall camp, I truly believe he could

Das_Countach

12/9/24 7:31pm

At 5'10", I hope he's not a side-arm.

Plantagenet

12/9/24 8:25pm

Uhhh no, he’s never played the same level of competition

ChinaFan

12/9/24 9:56pm

He’s never had near the surrounding cast or coaching either. Goes both ways

palangi

12/9/24 10:24pm

That is what he should have been rated out of HS

Jericho

12/9/24 7:05pm

No way to determine that

Cougrrrs Roll

12/9/24 7:10pm

You can absolutely have too many QBs, especially with rosters getting smaller

tacallaway

12/9/24 7:11pm

I'm repeating what I've heard from coaches

Cougrrrs Roll

12/9/24 7:41pm

How is Hillstead still a RS Fresman going forward?

Charles Darwin

12/9/24 7:12pm

My error: he’ll be a redshirt sophomore. Corrected

mjmill

12/9/24 7:34pm

A lot of success is circumstantial.

whoneedscorners?

12/9/24 7:16pm

#NYJets

thegoodmeister

12/9/24 8:12pm

Yup

jaba166

12/10/24 3:42am

His ranking was that high because of the Covid season his brother had

KYU

12/9/24 7:18pm

His high school career was excellent.

PJMort

12/9/24 7:42pm

Isn’t Hillstead smaller than a short Isaac Wilson

BYU'01

12/9/24 7:44pm

<< Deleted >>

runnincoug

12/9/24 7:48pm

Hillstead listed at 5'10"

Cougrrrs Roll

12/9/24 7:50pm

so they’re probably the same

palangi

12/9/24 7:53pm

You think Hillstead is the first player to list his legit height (w/o cleats)?

BYU'01

12/9/24 8:10pm

Yep very first

palangi

12/9/24 10:25pm

Wilson is listed at 6'0"

ManicBlue

12/9/24 11:12pm

I’m not a fan of QBs shorter than 6 feet

texaskevin

12/9/24 8:11pm

I’d care more about the results

palangi

12/9/24 8:19pm

Go with the player that’s faster and more athletic

I'mBatman

12/9/24 7:49pm

McCae

kahuna

12/9/24 8:22pm

Hillstead was undeniably better against lesser competition as a true freshman

NYC and Japan

12/9/24 8:34pm

I don’t get this. Hillstead led USU in passing in 3 games: all G5 & all losses

BYU'01

12/9/24 8:49pm

It’s simple

I'mBatman

12/9/24 8:52pm

Wilson completed more passes, for more yards, against better teams & won games

BYU'01

12/9/24 9:37pm

Hillstead’s running ability is next level

deliciousmocha

12/10/24 12:45am

RE: I don’t get this. Hillstead led USU in passing in 3 games: all G5

NYC and Japan

12/9/24 9:24pm

They did not “have the same number of passing yards”

BYU'01

12/9/24 9:36pm

Hillstead had higher completion percentage and QB rating.

cwilke1

12/9/24 11:34pm

We should have them play one on one to find out

MaxxPower

12/9/24 8:56pm

I think given the right situation Isaac could be a dang good college QB. Kid is

Riseandshoutboys

12/9/24 9:23pm

Are you all out of faith, is this how you feel?

TunaNoCrust

12/9/24 9:41pm

Illusion never changed into something real

shaggy

12/9/24 10:52pm

Come on you skipped the best line 😭

Polecat

12/9/24 11:19pm

I’m going for the base skill and the one that has a chip on his shoulder to be a top tier QB. That is Wilson is my bet.

Rhino84

12/10/24 12:19am

I think that's hillstead who is buried on the depth chart itching for his chance

runnincoug

12/10/24 5:56am

He’s not buried. He’s 3rd string rn— Bohanon leaves and I’m pretty confident hes

Das_Countach

12/10/24 7:15am

Sounds like Hillstead will be motivated to start if given the chance. Nice chip

runnincoug

12/10/24 9:10am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad