His average OFEI ranking has been 34 since he took over. Throw out the best and

Dec 2, 2024
4:16:45pm

BYUCougarsFan All-American

worst year he's averaged 23rd, top 25 ranked offensive average. That's pretty dang good. Most would kill for a top-25 average offense.

Last year was the only down year.

I think people will be calling for Jay Hill's head in a few years too.

Source

Not to mention the improvement this year without much roster expansion:

BYU Football comparison at F+ (my favorite advanced analytics composite)

2023 2024
Overall #77 #19 (+58)

Offense #84 #37 (+47)
Defense #78 #25 (+53)
Specials #23 #6 (+17)

Complementary football. Complementary improvement.
— Geoff Johnston (@geoffjBYU) December 2, 2024

https://twitter.com/geoffjBYU/status/1863615024641589583

Also not to mention the offense and the defense are similar this year, but everyone loves Jay Hill and bags on AROD:

BYU offense:
FPI: 31
SP+: 35

BYU defense:
FPI: 24th
SP+: 26th

This a much more complete football team than anyone cares to admit. Both sides had fits and starts. Both sides had moments where they were carried by the other. But they were statistically about the same.
— Joe Wheat (@joewheat27) December 1, 2024