So why are we even having this conversation? Do you think 11-1 PSU or ISU

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 2, 2024
4:00:29pm

reddead All-American

So why are we even having this conversation? Do you think 11-1 PSU or ISU

shouldn't be in over BYU?

Report problem with this ad

reddead

Bio page: reddead
Joined: Nov 16, 2009
Last login: Dec 3, 2024
Total posts: 5,581 (9 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

So let me get this straight, despite the BIG12 being a stronger conference this year than the BIG10, the BIG10 gets 4

MHallDidNothingWr0ng Nice Leather Pants

Dec 2, 9:08am

I don't agree with it but the chart you are posting

cougarfann888

Dec 2, 9:10am

Their top 5 are only "better" due to poll intertia.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Dec 2, 9:15am

So did they use a different criteria for top 5 analysis than they did for whole

cougarfann888

Dec 2, 9:19am

If their Top 5 are playing and beating worse teams, on average, than B12 teams,

Dec 2, 9:57am

There is no proof that they are better. Just opinion.

WJCougar

Dec 2, 9:17am

And Ohio State lost to Michigan.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Dec 2, 9:20am

The expansion of the playoff was simply to bring more money to the SEC and B1G. If it was fair they would have vetoed it

JohnnyComeLately

Dec 2, 9:10am

Oregon is undefeated; Penn St and Indiana have one loss

reddead

Dec 2, 9:34am

Here's an entire thread that goes into deep detail on why everything you said, other than brand bias, is wrong.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Dec 2, 9:50am

His thread doesn't do a good job w/Indiana, an 11-1 team with no brand bias

reddead

Dec 2, 10:03am

Indiana has a terrible schedule and they lost to the only good team they played.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Dec 2, 10:53am

Which Big XII losses are better than IU dropping a game at Ohio State?

reddead

Dec 2, 11:03am

Which Indiana wins are better than the BIG12s top wins? Their schedule is on par with a MWC schedule.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Dec 2, 11:34am

So treat them like Boise and put them in... 11-1 in a P4 conference

reddead

Dec 2, 11:46am

Only 1 loss, so you can't argue too much about keeping them out.

JuicyJam

Dec 2, 10:06am

Name the impressive wins of a Big XII team that will be kept out. Go ahead

reddead

Dec 2, 10:07am

BYU over SMU

JuicyJam

Dec 2, 10:17am

And BYU has a loss that is much, much worse than anyone else in the field

reddead

Dec 2, 10:22am

Like I said, only one loss so you can't argue too much about keeping them out.

JuicyJam

Dec 2, 10:41am

NIU is worse than Kansas? Really? How so?

reddead

Dec 2, 11:02am

RE: NIU is worse than Kansas? Really? How so?

JuicyJam

Dec 2, 11:40am

Now do BYU and Ohio State 🙂

reddead

Dec 2, 11:47am

Why? I think Ohio State is better than BYU

JuicyJam

Dec 2, 12:12pm

So why are we even having this conversation? Do you think 11-1 PSU or ISU

reddead

Dec 2, 4:00pm

Notre Dames loss to NIU is way worse. And they're ranked #4.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Dec 2, 10:54am

How so? NIU is going bowling (7-5), Kansas is not (5-7)

reddead

Dec 2, 11:00am

Lololol, NIU lost to Ball State, Miami of Ohio, Buffalo, NC State, and Toledo. While Kansas lost to some of the top

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Dec 2, 11:38am

How do BYU or Colorado (or ISU/ASU) compare to Ohio State?

reddead

Dec 2, 11:47am

The claim the Big 10 is rated lower

BYU71

Dec 2, 9:54am

Indiana played FIU, WIU and Charlotte.

WJCougar

Dec 2, 10:00am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad