Here's an entire thread that goes into deep detail on why everything you said, other than brand bias, is wrong.

Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Dec 2, 2024
9:50:40am

MHallDidNothingWr0ng Nice Leather Pants

Here's an entire thread that goes into deep detail on why everything you said, other than brand bias, is wrong.

I was going to try and write a long thread today, thoughtfully outlining why the committee’s bias towards Ohio State, Notre Dame, and Penn state is a positive feedback loop that keeps them all highly ranked, while SMU & BYU have are in a committee induced negative feedback loop…
— Brian Fagan (@bdfagan) December 2, 2024

https://twitter.com/bdfagan/status/1863480518987407690

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Dec 2, 2024 at 9:50:40am

Message modified by MHallDidNothingWr0ng on Dec 2, 2024 at 9:50:46am

Report problem with this ad

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

Previous username: CougarTailDevourer
Bio page: MHallDidNothingWr0ng
Joined: Nov 11, 2016
Last login: Dec 2, 2024
Total posts: 24,849 (4,007 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

So let me get this straight, despite the BIG12 being a stronger conference this year than the BIG10, the BIG10 gets 4

MHallDidNothingWr0ng Nice Leather Pants

9:08am

I don't agree with it but the chart you are posting

cougarfann888

9:10am

Their top 5 are only "better" due to poll intertia.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

9:15am

So did they use a different criteria for top 5 analysis than they did for whole

cougarfann888

9:19am

If their Top 5 are playing and beating worse teams, on average, than B12 teams,

9:57am

There is no proof that they are better. Just opinion.

WJCougar

9:17am

And Ohio State lost to Michigan.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

9:20am

The expansion of the playoff was simply to bring more money to the SEC and B1G. If it was fair they would have vetoed it

JohnnyComeLately

9:10am

Oregon is undefeated; Penn St and Indiana have one loss

reddead

9:34am

Here's an entire thread that goes into deep detail on why everything you said, other than brand bias, is wrong.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

9:50am

His thread doesn't do a good job w/Indiana, an 11-1 team with no brand bias

reddead

10:03am

Indiana has a terrible schedule and they lost to the only good team they played.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

10:53am

Which Big XII losses are better than IU dropping a game at Ohio State?

reddead

11:03am

Which Indiana wins are better than the BIG12s top wins? Their schedule is on par with a MWC schedule.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

11:34am

So treat them like Boise and put them in... 11-1 in a P4 conference

reddead

11:46am

Only 1 loss, so you can't argue too much about keeping them out.

JuicyJam

10:06am

Name the impressive wins of a Big XII team that will be kept out. Go ahead

reddead

10:07am

BYU over SMU

JuicyJam

10:17am

And BYU has a loss that is much, much worse than anyone else in the field

reddead

10:22am

Like I said, only one loss so you can't argue too much about keeping them out.

JuicyJam

10:41am

NIU is worse than Kansas? Really? How so?

reddead

11:02am

RE: NIU is worse than Kansas? Really? How so?

JuicyJam

11:40am

Now do BYU and Ohio State 🙂

reddead

11:47am

Why? I think Ohio State is better than BYU

JuicyJam

12:12pm

Notre Dames loss to NIU is way worse. And they're ranked #4.

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

10:54am

How so? NIU is going bowling (7-5), Kansas is not (5-7)

reddead

11:00am

Lololol, NIU lost to Ball State, Miami of Ohio, Buffalo, NC State, and Toledo. While Kansas lost to some of the top

MHallDidNothingWr0ng

11:38am

How do BYU or Colorado (or ISU/ASU) compare to Ohio State?

reddead

11:47am

The claim the Big 10 is rated lower

BYU71

9:54am

Indiana played FIU, WIU and Charlotte.

WJCougar

10:00am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad