Rankings don’t support claims of a tail off. They’ve been pretty constant.

Dec 1, 2024
3:33:49pm

chilawcoug Playmaker

But I meant year over year, which given injuries, different opponents, weather, etc. is the better measure statistically

Report problem with this ad

chilawcoug

Bio page: chilawcoug
Joined: Mar 6, 2021
Last login: Dec 1, 2024
Total posts: 2,837 (2 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

BYU's record the last 5 years: 11-1, 10-3, 8-5, 5-7, 10-2. Offense really

byusage

3:12pm

11-1, 10-3, & 8-5 and you get rid of your DC. Weird.

foofcoug

3:14pm

Because the defensive philosophy was wrong. ARod has the correct offensive

byusage

3:19pm

RE: Because the defensive philosophy was wrong. ARod has the correct offensive

foofcoug

3:21pm

No he doesn’t. He sure doesn’t recruit or coach like someone who says they want to be a run dominant team.

runningryan

4:26pm

Tuiaki is the reason ARod sucks.

bluecougar1985

3:21pm

Do we have a coordinator who has put together multiple units that are the

chilawcoug

3:21pm

CB told me you'd be crazy to fire a coordinator after successful seasons.

foofcoug

3:22pm

As someone who wanted Tuiaki gone in 2017, that was the minority by mid-2022,

chilawcoug

3:28pm

The offense just finished 11 of 16 in the conference.

bluecougar1985

3:31pm

Before this week 45th nationally (no FEI update yet). That’s far from our worst

chilawcoug

3:36pm

Our defense was 1st. Our offense held us back big time this year.

bluecougar1985

3:51pm

Did you read my post or respond to a hypothetical post you imagined?

chilawcoug

3:53pm

A Rod is mediocrity. Keep rolling with him and you’ll get exactly that

runningryan

4:28pm

That would be a disaster if the 45th best offense went 5-7. What defense do you

chilawcoug

4:30pm

Think Tuiaki cause that’s what we had before

runningryan

4:32pm

Man holding ARod to the standard of having to deal with a Tuiaki defense is

chilawcoug

4:33pm

No it’s not. The guy has consistently had one of the worst 3rd conversion percentages in FBS

runningryan

4:40pm

Interesting. None of your post explained at all about why we should judge

chilawcoug

4:45pm

Accomplishments are the mark of success, not records

runningryan

4:56pm

Man, another post that didn’t respond to anything I said. Have a good night.

chilawcoug

5:00pm

Oh I responded but you are just choosing not think about it

runningryan

5:03pm

Falling dead the last 4 games of the season is an upward trajectory? Maybe I

foofcoug

3:32pm

Rankings don’t support claims of a tail off. They’ve been pretty constant.

chilawcoug

3:33pm

Points do.

foofcoug

3:35pm

Good thing I’m not dumb enough to compare points

chilawcoug

3:36pm

Yeah, stats rankings win games - not points scored... dumb.

foofcoug

3:37pm

If you can’t understand that points are dependent on number of drives, and that

chilawcoug

3:39pm

The opposing QB successes was glaring. Multiple qbs had career days against

byusage

3:31pm

Still had wins. Lots of them. There's been some pretty glaring deficiencies on

foofcoug

3:34pm

Sent before finished. The offensive deficiencies are not consistent like

byusage

3:36pm

lol at comparing a season with the 45th best offense in the second year P4

chilawcoug

3:37pm

Keep holding on to Arod and you'll never hold a conference championship trophy.

foofcoug

3:40pm

Would the 4th best offense in the country be good enough?

chilawcoug

3:41pm

We'll have to see. Hit me up when they win that trophy in the future.

foofcoug

3:43pm

See this is what’s funny. You’re calling for a real-life person’s job and don’t

chilawcoug

3:50pm

Show me the conference championship trophy from 2021. He hasn't already done it.

foofcoug

3:52pm

If you think that the 4th ranked offense in the country is incapable of winning

chilawcoug

3:55pm

Did he reach that in the Big XII? Let's see him do that in a P4 conference. As

foofcoug

3:56pm

It’s adjusted for opponent. We played 7 P5 schools.

chilawcoug

4:01pm

Was it done in the context of playing in a conference and competing

foofcoug

4:06pm

lol cool, dude. More doubling down, dodging, and goalpost shifting.

chilawcoug

4:08pm

You're the one comparing apples to oranges...

foofcoug

4:10pm

We’ll never win a conference championship with you as a fan.

chilawcoug

4:11pm

We've already won a buttload of them. And a National Championship.

foofcoug

4:16pm

A P4 conference championship we haven’t.

chilawcoug

4:18pm

Please go back and correct your previous post. Talk about moving the goalposts..

foofcoug

4:19pm

Goalposts. That’s another problem. We can’t afford new ones with you as a fan.

chilawcoug

4:27pm

How can you say that when BYU was right there in the mix? Middle of the pack?

byusage

3:44pm

Did they get to the CCG? Did they win the championship? Write me when they do

foofcoug

3:45pm

Yes because with ARod we’ll never not have a pooch punt hit our own player and

chilawcoug

3:51pm

And his 3 points scored the entire 2nd half in that same game. But it's ALL on

foofcoug

3:54pm

Are you responding to my post or a hypothetical post you imagined in your mind?

chilawcoug

3:56pm

Obviously your post. You brought up the pooch punt in the Kansas game, I replied

foofcoug

3:58pm

I never excused or minimized the second half production, which your post accused

chilawcoug

4:03pm

The pooch punt is meaningless if the offense had any sort of pulse.

foofcoug

4:08pm

RE: The pooch punt is meaningless if the offense had any sort of pulse.

chilawcoug

4:09pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad