2004 Beck: 15 TDs to 8 INTs, 55% completion percentage. 2024 Retz: 18 TDs to

Nov 17, 2024
8:44:57am

oxcoug Intervention Needed

8 INTs, 58.4% completion percentage.

2004 Beck and 2024 Retz are the same age and both in their second year in the BYU system and have about the same number of starts at this point.

This message has been modified

Originally posted on Nov 17, 2024 at 8:44:57am

Message modified by oxcoug on Nov 17, 2024 at 8:45:18am

Report problem with this ad

oxcoug

Bio page: oxcoug
Joined: Jan 22, 2002
Last login: Nov 17, 2024
Total posts: 113,419 (20,435 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

It's time to bench Jake. Coaches don't trust him to pass in the red zone.

BIG XII Coug Unemployed BIG XII advisor

8:33am

Gerry hasn't played a game in almost three years, Jake is 9-1 this year as a starter.

2FarGone

8:35am

They apparently do trust him by continuing to let him throw fades.

GfB

8:35am

He has had a couple of mediocre games but he has also had some really good ones.

Colorado

8:37am

He had a bad one last night against a bad defense. Even Houston scored 2 TDs

russkiejedi

8:43am

Classic fan behavior. Call for the backup QB. JR did not have a good game

LifeLongLakerFan

8:39am

I assume trolling here, bc if it's not it's a really dumb post.

oxcoug

8:40am

RE: It's time to bench Jake. Coaches don't trust him to pass in the red zone.

Carnac

8:43am

2004 Beck: 15 TDs to 8 INTs, 55% completion percentage. 2024 Retz: 18 TDs to

oxcoug

8:44am

2004 Beck team was a loser, FYI

byuTX

8:46am

Whatever that means, he was given a chance to become great, and he did.

oxcoug

8:47am

JR next year will be the same as this year. He doesn’t have “it” and never will. He’s a known commodity

byuTX

8:50am

That's just, like, your subjective opinion. Tons of CBers hammered Beck even in

oxcoug

8:53am

But you can see how similar stats, ages and number of starts aren’t the same as talent right? Or do you think

byuTX

8:58am

I know Jo Beck was an NFL QB. I think JR probably isn't. So yes. I see that gap.

oxcoug

9:53am

2004 Beck was a true sophomore return missionary. Jake is a redshirt junior.

russkiejedi

8:49am

Beck also had arm talent and a head for the game

byuTX

8:51am

That's not what a WHOLE bunch of CBers thought in 2004 AND 2005 when he was

oxcoug

8:56am

Beck wasn't a redshirt junior with one more year of eligibility in 2004.

russkiejedi

9:02am

2004 Beck was the exact same age and same year in the program as 2024 Retz.

oxcoug

8:56am

I look forward to Jake finally putting it together in his first season with the

russkiejedi

9:24am

He’s not good enough to even go semi pro

byuTX

9:28am

Sound Logic. Put in a QB who hasn't played in almost 3 seasons. I love how

wildlandfireguy

8:52am

RE: It's time to bench Jake. Coaches don't trust him to pass in the red zone.

acougfan

8:53am

I say stick with Jake this year but hit the portal hard. Maybe borrow some of that AJ money

byuTX

9:03am

No one is going to start over Jake as a senior, barring injury

2FarGone

9:05am

Of course not

byuTX

9:05am

If Jake hands the ball off last night instead of throwing a pick on a fade, the outcome may be different. Jake's

Posting on CougarBoard