My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Nov 14, 2024
7:22
:09
pm
MarylandFan
Truly Addicted User
I think the prevailing justification here is "choose your own adventure"
Whatever the voters/committee think is what it is, even if it's inconsistent team to team or something.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
MarylandFan
Previous username
CougarinMaryland
Bio page
MarylandFan
Joined
Sep 4, 2010
Last login
Nov 14, 2024
Total posts
18,102 (291 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
People rank BYU high because they have 2 top 20 wins and are undefeated. Other people vote BYU lower because they beat
foofcoug
Wonder what the character limi
Nov 14, 6:42pm
They can't have it both ways though. Other top 10 teams have similar resumes.
MarylandFan
Nov 14, 6:53pm
They can and they do. As I said, it's subjective and people have biases.
foofcoug
Nov 14, 6:56pm
You just said they're not wrong in that bias about BYU's losses.
MarylandFan
Nov 14, 7:04pm
They may be wrong according to you. It doesn't mean they're wrong.
foofcoug
Nov 14, 7:09pm
I'm happy to blow up the "close losses" myth anytime
MarylandFan
Nov 14, 7:18pm
People whining about it got BYU a higher ranking this week.
WizeGuise
Nov 14, 7:11pm
What about the latter group who doesn't hit Texas the same for barely winning? I'm good with either; just be consistent
unctoothman
Nov 14, 7:13pm
Were Texas' close wins against teams on long losing streaks like BYU's? There's always ways people can delineate.
foofcoug
Nov 14, 7:17pm
I get that everyone has different criteria, and that's fine. Just be consistent with whatever criteria you use, is my
unctoothman
Nov 14, 7:19pm
I think the prevailing justification here is "choose your own adventure"
MarylandFan
Nov 14, 7:22pm
Which is fine for pollsters. But shouldn't be the case for the CFP committee. Have criteria and stick to them, not just
unctoothman
Nov 14, 7:25pm
Then you're asking humans to not be human.
foofcoug
Nov 14, 7:25pm
Humans don’t have a good psychological defense mechanism
WizeGuise
Nov 14, 7:32pm
THAT IS THE POINT OF SPORTS RANKINGS. They are underermined, which makes them...
RoboKayne
Nov 14, 8:35pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad