I'm imagining a scenario where Boise State wins out and we lose in the CCG. In..

Sign up, and you can customize which countdowns you see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Nov 5, 2024
5:49:12pm

Team Chaos All-American

I'm imagining a scenario where Boise State wins out and we lose in the CCG. In..

...that scenario, the Big 12 champ takes a spot, and that SEC and B1G two-loss teams pass BYU.

Report problem with this ad

Team Chaos

Previous username: Sock Gnome
Bio page: Team Chaos
Joined: Sep 6, 2002
Last login: Nov 5, 2024
Total posts: 15,419 (1 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

The most a team has dropped in the rankings after losing a CCG? 4 spots

5:43pm

If BYU wins 4 of its next 5 games it is probably in.

5:44pm

12-1 and we are in

5:44pm

If we win the CCG. I don't see it otherwise. I think the rankings today proved..

Team Chaos

5:45pm

Nah, that's silly to penalize a team for playing in the CCG

5:45pm

It's silly, but it's reality.

Team Chaos

5:46pm

It's not, though. There is no precedent for a team dropping that far in the

5:47pm

I'm imagining a scenario where Boise State wins out and we lose in the CCG. In..

Team Chaos

5:49pm

Boise State is already in - they aren't taking someone's spot

5:50pm

They already have. There's only one team from the Big 12 in right now.

Team Chaos

5:51pm

Not all the top 12 teams will win the rest of their games

5:53pm

That's not what I mean. There will be other teams in the SEC or B1G that are...

Team Chaos

5:56pm

It’s silly to think this has anything to do with objectivity.

DiamondMo

5:52pm

Unfortunately that’s the case.

acadian8

5:49pm

Yeah, don't get your hopes up for them sticking with that standard for BYU

5:44pm

It's tough to explain how a team sitting at home should jump a team playing for

5:45pm

But that's the reality when you're up against the SEC and B1G.

Team Chaos

5:46pm

12 wins > 11 wins

5:46pm

That would matter if you or I were on the committee. Not as presently constitute

Team Chaos

5:47pm

That scenario isn't supported by history

5:48pm

There is no history. This is the first year of a 12-team playoff. You're making

Team Chaos

5:49pm

There is history of the CFP rankings

5:50pm

That's not even close to the same thing. Those rankings only mattered to the...

Team Chaos

5:52pm

It mattered for NY6 games

5:53pm

No, it didn't. Those bowls weren't obligated to take CFP-ranked teams.

Team Chaos

5:57pm

Rankings are ALWAYS about recency bias. A loss last week is like 2 losses early.

MarylandFan

5:46pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad