It wasn’t the injury to Rising that cost him the job

Sign up, and you'll be able to customize your font size and more! Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Oct 21, 2024
11:12:59am

donnerstag All-American

It wasn’t the injury to Rising that cost him the job

It was the fact that a true freshman who clearly isn’t ready is QB2. That is a huge indictment to Ludwig that nobody else in the QB room is better than true freshman Wilson. They would be so much better off if they had a player like Bohannon as QB2

Report problem with this ad

donnerstag

Bio page: donnerstag
Joined: Feb 22, 2005
Last login: Oct 21, 2024
Total posts: 39,942 (702 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

I just never thought I'd see PK like this

EM_Puma

Oct 21, 11:01am

Eh. No thanks.

kccougar

Oct 21, 11:02am

I agree..we should start treating KSL the way we treat the sltrib.

Chase

Oct 21, 2:49pm

Did you base this opinion on watching 10 mins of KSL in the past 10 yrs?

yahtzee

Oct 21, 3:26pm

Absolutely

Chase

Oct 21, 4:43pm

You must be some kind of sports news savant. You are averaging only

yahtzee

Oct 21, 4:50pm

Hahaha. The more you defend KSL, the stronger my conviction to spread the truth:

Chase

Oct 21, 4:58pm

you're missing the much larger point here.

yahtzee

Oct 21, 5:13pm

I've become more and more disenchanted with KSL over the past few years.

MVPlayer

Oct 21, 8:18pm

Well sounds like you spent a good amount of time evaluating

yahtzee

Oct 21, 8:37pm

I used to listen to a lot of PK way back. He’s not pro or anti anything. He

Polecat

Oct 21, 11:04am

PK is pro-whatever gets him listeners and clicks.

Oct 21, 11:23am

Yeah that’s the industry he’s in. though I think he’s pretty tame as far as

Polecat

Oct 21, 11:28am

He's unashamedly Pro-ASU. Otherwise. I've always thought he's been fair to BYU.

jtm0001

Oct 21, 11:33am

Yeah but even his ASU fanhood is often a joke. Back when I listened I thought

Polecat

Oct 21, 11:42am

The headline is wrong. It wasn’t Cam’s injuries that cost Ludwig his job, it was his lack of contingency planning. If

SpecialT

Oct 21, 11:09am

But K-tWhitt himself said it was the deepest team ever.

Brandoblueblood

Oct 21, 11:17am

I think there’s enough blame to pass around to both the OC and the HC.

SpecialT

Oct 21, 11:21am

Wait, but I thought their third string quarterback would start on any team in the big 12

Dr MoBYU

Oct 21, 12:38pm

Ludwig had a QB who "should" have been ready at some point last season

reddead

Oct 21, 1:44pm

Huard not having spring ball means very few reps to learn the offense

donnerstag

Oct 21, 2:12pm

I actually agree with you that it was probably not worthy of a “firing”, but given the hype this year, there had to be a

SpecialT

Oct 21, 2:13pm

QB is not really a "next man up" position, especially in the transfer portal era

reddead

Oct 21, 2:51pm

It wasn’t the injury to Rising that cost him the job

donnerstag

Oct 21, 11:12am

I'm sure there is a political component. The Wilson family was really pushing for Zach to start at BYU as a FR, IIRC,

Bob Vance

Oct 21, 11:26am

If he’s not as good as others on the bench, Ludwig deserves to be fired then too

donnerstag

Oct 21, 11:41am

Could also have been out of his hands (i.e., a Whitt decision). Too little info

Bob Vance

Oct 21, 12:05pm

Yet, I saw tOSU bring on a true freshman QB and he led them to a natty. This

EM_Puma

Oct 21, 12:07pm

It’s certainly possible to be great as a true freshman

donnerstag

Oct 21, 2:08pm

I'm sure there's more to it than that

reddead

Oct 21, 1:49pm

Huard is a junior and came after spring ball

donnerstag

Oct 21, 2:07pm

Here's Huard's bio on the Ute's own site. Listed as a Senior

reddead

Oct 21, 2:44pm

It was a pretty big gamble to bank on a true freshman as the backup

donnerstag

Oct 21, 3:50pm

What would you have done instead? Are other programs able to do better?

reddead

Oct 21, 4:38pm

Easy. Bring a veteran transfer to compete with Rising in spring ball

donnerstag

Oct 21, 5:37pm

It's a cardinal sin to put all of your eggs in the QB basket.

Schrodizzy

Oct 21, 11:36am

Not a bad article, but his premise is completely wrong...

lbmango

Oct 21, 12:33pm

Well said

Atmospheric_Cougar

Oct 21, 1:40pm

QBs really are that important. It's why NFL teams pay through the nose for them

reddead

Oct 21, 1:58pm

He's one of the few neutral media members in Utah (ASU grad). He takes jabs at

arizonacougarfan

Oct 21, 1:46pm

he's not in anyone's came, except ASU

dixieutahbyuzag

Oct 21, 2:03pm

PK is the best in the business but he is frequently unkind to DJ. He also must

caretoomuch

Oct 21, 2:45pm

PK is friends with as many local coaches as he can be. That's how the business

yahtzee

Oct 21, 3:32pm

The majority of Sports media personnel in SLC lean ute. Even

Chase

Oct 21, 2:54pm

I may be an outlier here, but I honestly like listening to DJ & PK.

Dwide_Schrude

Oct 21, 4:33pm

He can sense the winds of change. BYU is becoming the biggest story in the state

Oct 21, 5:41pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad