baseball.
Can he read and track a ball well like an outfielder - absolutely. The way he glides the ball going over his head is not a misread but how you track a baseball as an outfielder.
But then he thinks he can catch a punt the same way and that is not the way it's done when you want to make high percentage catches. A football isn't a baseball in shape, speed or rotation and his belief he can make an over the shoulder catch is going to hurt us.