Jaren should be higher than Zach. He actually beat Utah. Almost single-handedly

Report problem with this ad

Aug 2, 2024
11:54:21am

Magneto Starter

Jaren should be higher than Zach. He actually beat Utah. Almost single-handedly

Report problem with this ad

Magneto

Bio page: Magneto
Joined: Jul 1, 2022
Last login: Sep 18, 2024
Total posts: 6,212 (16 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Results of QB ranking survey. 58 Total votes.

Aug 2, 11:10am

I'll update results later if you still want to take it. Link to survey:

Aug 2, 11:14am

Marc Wilson and Gifford Nielsen are way too high

Aug 2, 11:16am

No way.

BlueFever

Aug 2, 11:23am

I agree they’re foundational to the BYU QB factory. But isn’t the foundation at the bottom? BYU built up from them

Aug 2, 11:32am

Virgil Carter was the foundation. It was there when they came along.

Bullrider

Aug 2, 11:40am

Carter predates the factory.

BlueFever

Aug 2, 11:56am

Sorry, I see him as the beginning along with three old geysers I asked feel.

Bullrider

Aug 2, 4:50pm

It's more about who had greater impact on their time.

BlueFever

Aug 2, 11:57am

The Hall v Wilson results are surprising.

rtNelson

Aug 2, 11:27am

Taysom is the worst passer of them all by far. Surprised he is that high.

Aug 2, 11:33am

And the best runner by a lot. Question isn’t *only* passing. But I agree he’s probably high by actual BYU career. If

mvtoro

Aug 2, 1:07pm

Jaren should be higher than Zach. He actually beat Utah. Almost single-handedly

Magneto

Aug 2, 11:54am

Zach woulda beat them if he’d had Tyler Allgeier at RB lol

puntersarepeople

Aug 2, 12:18pm

Tyler Allgeier might be the best RB BYU has had. He was incredible!

Aug 2, 12:25pm

His punch out vs ASU is an all-time play. Usually a RB is a QBs friend because he takes pressure off the pass game. Not

mvtoro

Aug 2, 1:19pm

Tyler put the game away at the end but Jaren’s runs and passes to Nacua were out

Magneto

Aug 2, 1:45pm

Zach had an amazing game vs the Utes once but got stuck with having a 4th string

puntersarepeople

Aug 2, 3:14pm

The problem with most QB rankings is we base them too much on record and team performance. He’s the most important

mvtoro

Aug 2, 1:16pm

Recency bias there. Gifford #4, Mark Wilson #5. Also, Hall and Doman ahead of Z Wilson.

roseyscenario

Aug 2, 1:40pm

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad