Here's the deal: Breaking Bad was a great show, but I think it's consistently overrated.

Report problem with this ad

Jul 7, 2024
6:25:16pm

Supercoug [censored]

Report problem with this ad

Supercoug

Bio page: Supercoug
Joined: Sep 7, 2005
Last login: Oct 5, 2024
Total posts: 56,861 (28,692 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Aggregated rankings of best TV shows of all time

RSL This is my dupe account

Jul 7, 6:02pm

I like the ratings on the far right. Breaking bad and GOT are the only two good

DieHarder

Jul 7, 6:04pm

Yeah, that seems to be a pretty bad outlier that skews the rankings

cougaman

Jul 7, 6:56pm

I'm surprised Succession is that low. I'd put it at least top 5.

P-Boy Squad

Jul 7, 6:06pm

GOTs final two seasons are so atrocious I can't even put it in the top 20

CSoul

Jul 7, 6:06pm

I think the opposite. The first 6 seasons are so good that some people now underrate it

TCuz

Jul 7, 6:10pm

The last two episodes of Season 6 are peak TV.

RealTaysomHill

Jul 7, 6:41pm

Both post source material too. They were on the right track

TCuz

Jul 7, 6:47pm

The first 6 aren't good enough for me to do that. I read the books before the show and it got weaker

CSoul

Jul 7, 7:28pm

Sorry that's not how it works

TNT

Jul 7, 7:47pm

Sure it is. I’m rewatching it right now and it’s still great

RealTaysomHill

Jul 7, 8:56pm

Ian McShane nailed it

Gustav

Jul 7, 8:45pm

Sherlock and Fleabag are the biggest surprises for me.

SpecialT

Jul 7, 6:07pm

Chernobyl……am I missing that one? Not really heard much about it.

Idacoug

Jul 7, 6:09pm

Yes.

Bonoman

Jul 7, 6:11pm

It's great. I think mini series should be disqualified from a list like this. Easier to not have let down seasons

P-Boy Squad

Jul 7, 6:13pm

I agree that miniseries should have their own rankings, separate from true

Japan Coug

Jul 7, 7:02pm

But wait! It gets more complicated. What about series like True Detective,

Cougar Junkie

Jul 7, 7:11pm

It was fine. I couldn't finish it.

Supercoug

Jul 7, 6:24pm

It’s amazing. Deals with truth and bureaucracy.

Art Director

Jul 7, 6:41pm

Great show.

Japan Coug

Jul 7, 6:59pm

Always Sunny is too low. Surprised to see Battlestar Galactica that high.

joelvandyne

Jul 7, 6:10pm

I see they snuck Justified in there to keep TNT happy!😀

Bonoman

Jul 7, 6:10pm

Yeah, but no Wonder Woman 😦

Cougar Junkie

Jul 7, 6:12pm

But where is 24?

TNT

Jul 7, 7:48pm

On continual loop at TNT's dwelling

Cougar Junkie

Jul 7, 7:57pm

RE: On continual loop at TNT's dwelling

TNT

Jul 7, 8:34pm

No Monk? No Psych.. No thanks.

TheLost

Jul 7, 6:11pm

I feel like there's a lot of recency bias on there. The top 10 are all from the

mannheimadler

Jul 7, 6:12pm

Yeah, no MASH, Cheers or Cosby Show? Doesn’t make sense.

SpecialT

Jul 7, 6:14pm

Or Frasier. Come on, man.

Cougar Junkie

Jul 7, 6:15pm

Seinfeld? Cheers? Mash? Cosby show? Frasier?

Idacoug

Jul 7, 6:16pm

recency bias

Supercoug

Jul 7, 6:16pm

I'm a hack (but a correct hack, so there's that)

Supercoug

Jul 7, 6:19pm

Seinfeld is way too low, and so is The Americans. Friends and Stranger Things

Japan Coug

Jul 7, 6:21pm

I've only ever seen one of the top 10 (Stranger Things), and 3 of the top 25.

CopperLix

Jul 7, 6:24pm

Here's the deal: Breaking Bad was a great show, but I think it's consistently overrated.

Supercoug

Jul 7, 6:25pm

Go back to BBQ reviews. TV is not your thing.

SpecialT

Jul 7, 6:35pm

Life is clearly not your thing. Act accordingly.

Sid Vicious

Jul 8, 10:12am

My take is that BB gets rave reviews because it was so new/different in style.

RSL

Jul 7, 6:39pm

Personally I think this is how GOT will be looked at in the future as well. The whole premise of the books

CSoul

Jul 7, 7:31pm

<< Deleted >>

Gustav

Jul 7, 9:06pm

Justified is somewhere between 20-40 spots too low.

d-coug

Jul 7, 6:47pm

Where’s M*A*S*H?

Frankfromtheballpark

Jul 7, 7:31pm

It’s in there. Number 15

byuTX

Jul 8, 8:12am

According to people who have never seen classic tv shows before 2000

CatamountFan

Jul 7, 7:38pm

Game of Thrones? Ugh

TNT

Jul 7, 7:46pm

Where is Homeland? That show is straight fire.

Jelly Man

Jul 7, 7:56pm

Spot on!

Cougar Junkie

Jul 7, 7:58pm

What is that rightmost ranking site? 91 for BB and 100 for GoT and everything else is like 20.

supertux

Jul 7, 8:44pm

Terrible list IMO

Gustav

Jul 7, 9:02pm

#38 "Mare" of Easttown?

misterpepper

Jul 7, 9:27pm

A great miniseries

Cougar Junkie

Jul 7, 9:31pm

Ah, I was thinking of Mayor of Kingstown

misterpepper

Jul 7, 9:59pm

Arrested Development is top 5 for me.

Posting on CougarBoard