If he gets back to his old form, all his critics will come around, I think. Dude is a HIGH level athlete w a good feel for the forceful side of the game.
In film, at least, he looks like a level of slasher & transition finisher we haven't seen at BYU in a long time. I'm tempted to say — that we've never seen. Athletically, he looks even faster & more explosive than Travis Hansen, too me — but with the same size & strength (but without as much skill).