Understood. My entire point is the certainty of 4 additional players has a value of more than zero, probably much more.

Report problem with this ad

May 22, 2024
10:05:21am

roseyscenario Work-in-Progress

Report problem with this ad

roseyscenario

Previous username: addedupon
Bio page: roseyscenario
Joined: Jul 15, 2011
Last login: Sep 20, 2024
Total posts: 24,175 (4,125 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Well, well, well. Look what the cat dragged home…

Crowd Factor

May 21, 11:52pm

That looks like a net negative to me

bYuFB

May 21, 11:54pm

Khalifa isn’t playing next year (surgery). Atiki was a great story and

Crowd Factor

May 22, 12:01am

Only commentary you have on Robinson is he's a "net negative," Yeah that's just

hardcorecoug

May 22, 12:33am

Pretty sure their commentary on Robinson is BYU is worse off without him.

TriForce

May 22, 10:12am

Adam's(SIC) was unproven, but Koz and Crawford aren't?

ochobeeguy

May 22, 8:21am

Adam’s injury clearly caused him to become

Crowd Factor

May 22, 5:20pm

Nah. I'd rather have people who wanna play for BYU. If those guys ...

KCFan85

May 22, 12:07am

I want to play for BYU, but I promise you, you'd rather have these guys

ryebrye

May 22, 4:27am

Keita didn't really "want" to play for BYU, he just followed his coach.

Zinger

May 22, 8:05am

If they were playing for BYU then they would want to be playing for BYU…

ochobeeguy

May 22, 8:21am

If the players we have who "want" to be here, were guaranteed a

Undefeated

May 22, 10:16am

I would want to know if they players who are here playing for BYU are here and

Plantagenet

May 22, 12:49pm

I disagree.

Love Cougs

May 22, 8:48am

Not if the latter three don't meltdown when things get tough.

BlueFever

May 22, 9:16am

Hey, if you like that, I’ve got $10 I’ll give you for a $100 bill.

Blue2thebone

May 22, 12:06am

Keep draggin, kitty! Think big & bloody!

SinkingQuffa

May 22, 1:49am

And Waterman

downtownchrisbrown

May 22, 5:44am

And if we're talking about team comparisons — this year vs last — we can't leave out SJ, either.

SinkingQuffa

May 22, 5:47am

Agree, KY results have been positive on the roster building front, and much more to come, including a versatile PF.

roseyscenario

May 22, 6:32am

As it currently stands, we’re worse off than before the movement

Indy Coug

May 22, 6:38am

Counting the unfilled scholarships in hand? I don't buy that.

roseyscenario

May 22, 7:24am

It kind of depends on who fills them.

dYrtbYkerYder

May 22, 8:23am

Roster so far plus unknown fills of 4 spots with a top coach in the B12, odds favor improvement. Almost certainly

roseyscenario

May 22, 8:43am

Maybe count chickens when chickens hatch? Of course anything is possible, but,

Cougarbib

May 22, 9:23am

Chickens won't be hatched until next season is over. Discussion is assets: current roster + future fills vs last year.

roseyscenario

May 22, 9:36am

Discussion was “current status”. Than u for clarifying that your Rosey Outlook

Cougarbib

May 22, 9:44am

I guess that my concern is that the portal is closed and most HS recruits have

dYrtbYkerYder

May 22, 9:58am

Understood. My entire point is the certainty of 4 additional players has a value of more than zero, probably much more.

roseyscenario

May 22, 10:05am

“As it currently stands”? We’re in a loss position

Indy Coug

May 22, 8:45am

We differ on "currently stands." Value of current roster is an estimate, as is value of 4 future fills. IMO that adds up

roseyscenario

May 22, 9:53am

If one or two of the guys we add in the future aren't great locker room guys

downtownchrisbrown

May 22, 10:10am

I think differently, an expression of confidence Young is rational and reasonably competent, not a high bar. Rather, he

roseyscenario

May 22, 12:38pm

Thank u for admitting the Rosey view is that it is a coin toss as to whether

Cougarbib

May 22, 1:46pm

<< Deleted >>

roseyscenario

May 22, 1:54pm

Soupie tells me I should bow to your importance, so, wait……I guess I am

Cougarbib

May 22, 2:04pm

Sometimes it can be hard to predict. Even with Pope he had a great locker room

downtownchrisbrown

May 22, 2:03pm

Also, just to add. As the expression goes, it takes one bad apple to spoil the

downtownchrisbrown

May 22, 2:07pm

I agree which is why it's laudable that Young is taking time to be careful in roster building. I think he'll do well.

roseyscenario

May 22, 2:12pm

Who is placing zero value on 4 openings? Zero if they go unfilled like 1 did

Cougarbib

May 22, 11:17am

That stands to reason because for the moment we're not currently where we were

Plantagenet

May 22, 12:53pm

Yep, and one day closer to the “great and dreadful day of the Lord”

LCcoug

May 22, 6:46am

Chandler is the one I'd like to have back

Cougrrrs Roll

May 22, 9:56am

The last minute Waterman decision probably bodes well for future additions. If

BoiseBlueCoug

May 22, 10:45am

This is silly. Leaving because of who is being looked at when likelihood

Cougarbib

May 22, 11:21am

Reading through the thread, you win this round 🙂

Undefeated

May 22, 5:29pm

It is so hard to judge the open roster spots, they are still unknown

PumaFanatico

May 23, 11:41am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad