And then by who you want to be playing if you needed a GW drive. So to take your tiers, I'd rank them thus:

Aug 10, 2022
8:29:25pm

Spiff SequelTrilogyFan

Top tier: McMahon, Detmer, Young, Z Wilson, and Bosco.

2nd tier: Beck, Hall, Sarkisian,Mark Wilson, Giff Nielsen.

3rd tier: Walsh and Doman.

The fourth are all others.

Report problem with this ad

Spiff

Previous username: SpiffCoug
Bio page: Spiff
Joined: Sep 12, 2002
Last login: Jun 30, 2024
Total posts: 69,244 (5,842 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Do you rank greatest BYU QB's by entire BYU career, best season, or NFL success?

AFcoug7

8/10/22 4:06pm

All 3 should be considered but weighted in this order: BYU career, best season

Blueto

8/10/22 4:08pm

Most people who saw him play would say Jim McMahon was very special

LSUcougar92

8/10/22 4:10pm

And he was!

Armchaircoug

8/10/22 4:20pm

I don't hold a crappy defense against the QB. Beck's junior year was also very

Corn Pop

8/10/22 4:23pm

It seems fair to rank them first by their best season and then by career:

Archaea

8/10/22 5:06pm

And then by who you want to be playing if you needed a GW drive. So to take your tiers, I'd rank them thus:

Posting on CougarBoard