My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 16, 2020
5:30
:20
pm
buckles
Concussion Protocol
Yes
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
buckles
Bio page
buckles
Joined
Dec 21, 2011
Last login
Dec 19, 2020
Total posts
507 (4 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Interesting Discussion on Reddit - Would you guys be willing to make this trade?
ZacSeljaas'Stache
9/16/20 3:31pm
We already have one so I'd prefer them not win 2 and tie up the score.
Harbinger
9/16/20 3:33pm
I think i'd need to know how it happens.
Harbinger
9/16/20 3:36pm
So would you give up the 84 NC to displace Utah's 2 BCS runs?
TFL
9/16/20 3:39pm
What? Never said I'd give up our natty.
Harbinger
9/16/20 3:42pm
Yeah...but 2 for 1? Throw in a recency factor?
TFL
9/16/20 3:45pm
You're equating a BCS run with actually winning a natty?
kirty
9/16/20 3:58pm
Depends. Not true comparables. BYUs NC was awesome, a culmination of a great run. Did wonders for validating the program
TFL
9/16/20 4:35pm
Lol. You only wish it had an *
andrewg3
9/16/20 5:00pm
All one has to do is check the trophy case at both schools to know.
Harbinger
9/16/20 5:08pm
Not really, Never cool to take anything away from BYU's NC. It's special. But I was too young in 84
TFL
9/16/20 5:21pm
This^^^
Tuskaloosa Cougar
9/16/20 8:51pm
Can you show me where the * is? I've never seen one associated with 1984.
squidmark
9/16/20 8:52pm
National perception.
TFL
9/16/20 10:09pm
Uh wait, you are the only one giving it an *. The national media, NCAA, etc. all consider BYU the '84 NC with NO *.
TheLoneCougar
9/17/20 6:47am
Did you eat paint chips as a kid?
Ned Schneebly
9/17/20 6:55am
Amen!! People don't discuss BCA/BCS/NY6 victories. BYU does
BYUHgrad
9/17/20 6:29am
Let time run its course.
JL31
9/16/20 3:34pm
We just need to find a punter that can run for 19 yards when the pressures on
ZacSeljaas'Stache
9/16/20 3:35pm
Dude, too soon.
All-American
9/16/20 3:37pm
EVERYONE THINKS IT'S 19 YARDS & FORGETS THAT WE START 15 YARDS BACK FROM THE LOS
JL31
9/16/20 3:38pm
Johnny i love you man
IceWaterExtraIce
9/16/20 3:43pm
RE: Johnny i love you man
IceWaterExtraIce
9/16/20 3:44pm
Taysom could do it
darkcoug
9/16/20 3:52pm
Well you didn’t even make it back to the line of scrimmage so...
USMCdad
9/16/20 3:59pm
Hey he was only 23 yards short!
JohnnyComeLately
9/16/20 4:02pm
RE: Well you didn’t even make it back to the line of scrimmage so...
JL31
9/16/20 4:12pm
I loved the play. I didn't like the outcome, but I loved that you were gutsy
TailgateU
9/17/20 8:25am
RE: We just need to find a punter that can run for 19 yards when the pressures
CougarTwins
9/16/20 3:46pm
TPSA. Need someone to make hats.
CougarTwins
9/16/20 3:37pm
There's more truth to this than everyone realizes.
Y05
9/16/20 6:36pm
Yes I’d do that in a heartbeat.
Duke Silver
9/16/20 3:35pm
Utah already has their 2 asterisk championships. Do those count?
LiveCoug
9/16/20 3:36pm
No, fake "championships" do not count, nor should they.
neboutefan
9/16/20 3:56pm
Definitely.
WP17
9/16/20 3:37pm
I’d prefer to not hVe them win one ever.
Dr MoBYU
9/16/20 3:38pm
Worth it
Blueto
9/16/20 3:40pm
Shouldn't he be asking Utah about Colorado?
shoganai
9/16/20 3:40pm
I say no. It's petty, but no. I can't live with Utah winning a NC, let alone two
che flaco
9/16/20 3:44pm
Yes. Do it.
JadonY
9/16/20 3:51pm
We compete with our rival for recruits
Great38
9/16/20 3:52pm
Would be nice to be in the top 20 or better even if our rival did better also.
JadonY
9/16/20 5:08pm
Of course not! That one is easy.
Great38
9/16/20 3:51pm
No never.
YIsForBrigham
9/16/20 3:57pm
As a Texas Aggie and lifelong BYU fan, this question sucks. Never give the bad
TailgateU
9/16/20 4:05pm
A national championship would solidify BYU relevance again, even if Utah was still better
cheezedawg
9/16/20 4:09pm
Yes no brainer yes absolutely. Hate the Utes but love Cougs more. Plus
CougaRR4L
9/16/20 4:13pm
Maybe we can get a Utah guy to make the deal.
Blue Heart
9/16/20 4:21pm
1 to 0 is better than 2 to 2
ldssdl
9/16/20 4:23pm
Absolutely, no question.
DanSmith
9/16/20 4:35pm
I went back and forth on this, but ultimately decided YES. The state would have
RUNBYU1
9/16/20 5:37pm
Absolutely. If both BYU and Utah were nationally relevant, I'd be thrilled
Hill4Heisman
9/16/20 5:05pm
Yes
buckles
9/16/20 5:30pm
To the people saying yes because it would be good for the state and would make
che flaco
9/16/20 5:57pm
Cool. BYU and Texas are in the same tier of CFB.
Y05
9/16/20 6:32pm
What if the one we win is against them?
sah22
9/16/20 6:59pm
Yes, I'll take a BYU national championship. Don't care about the Utes either way
Reedme
9/16/20 8:06pm
Yes as long as our NC is the year after their 2nd one.
Bald Eagle
9/16/20 8:31pm
DEFINITELY
Sale
9/17/20 9:09am
I'm fine with Boise winning 2.
ochobeeguy
9/17/20 9:26am
I absolutely hate the U of U BUT...
CaughtForaTouchdown
9/17/20 10:25am
I question the sanity of anyone using PRC's REDDIT?
LEDSFW
9/17/20 10:28am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad