My Account
Sign up, and you'll be able to vote in polls.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Jul 12, 2019
10:51
:34
am
ManicBlue
All-American
RE: "Kalani may have a higher ceiling" just means he hasn't retired/been
Agreed but those years, BYU only faced 2 P5 schools during the regular season unlike the 5 we're seeing now to go along with the top level G5 schools on the schedule.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
ManicBlue
Bio page
ManicBlue
Joined
Jan 10, 2005
Last login
Sep 27, 2024
Total posts
51,382 (939 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
BYU vs G5 bowl eligible teams under Kalani Sitake
BYU Fan
7/12/19 9:52am
How does that align with historical BYU results?
Indy Coug
7/12/19 9:54am
You're the man to ask about that but I have to think pretty poorly
BYU Fan
7/12/19 9:57am
I checked 2001-2004 & 2005-2007 as well
BYU Fan
7/12/19 11:06am
Thoughts: 1) Bronco is a better coach than Kalani;
a priori
7/12/19 9:55am
Agreed. Why wouldn't a coaching staff that's been together for years be better
SUAVO
7/12/19 10:01am
Bronco was a new head coach and had a new staff once too.
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:03am
And his first 5 years were amazing
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:05am
Not saying that Kalani is a better coach, but why compare the last 5 years
SUAVO
7/12/19 10:23am
Bronco's first years would be even more of a discrepancy but the last years
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:26am
Still not surprising
SUAVO
7/12/19 10:28am
Because you agree that Bronco is a better coach?
a priori
7/12/19 10:30am
IMO Bronco has been the better consistently good coach but
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:32am
"Kalani may have a higher ceiling" just means he hasn't retired/been fired/etc
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:41am
RE: "Kalani may have a higher ceiling" just means he hasn't retired/been
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:51am
That's fine but it's also the only time BYU finished ranked 4 straight years
BYU Fan
7/12/19 11:10am
RE: That's fine but it's also the only time BYU finished ranked 4 straight years
ManicBlue
7/12/19 12:08pm
Not really. It’s more of an evaluation of how he runs things
puntersarepeople
7/12/19 1:21pm
I agree with this, but the first few years have not given me reason to be
a priori
7/12/19 10:43am
We know he has a lower floor.
coolblue
7/12/19 12:43pm
Bronco's teams went 11-3 vs G5 bowl eligible teams his first 3 years
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:45am
And Gary Crowton's teams went 7-9 his first 3 years
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:52am
I used 2013-2015 because they were the most recent years
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:34am
But he had been at BYU as a DC. Kalani had not coached
PessimisticCB
7/12/19 10:58am
Kalani played at BYU though. I'd call it a wash.
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:59am
When he played at BYU it was completely different.
PessimisticCB
7/12/19 11:01am
Regardless, he wasn't starting from scratch and Bronco had to deal with
ManicBlue
7/12/19 9:56pm
Bronco's job was harder. He brought the program back from the brink of death.
a priori
7/12/19 11:00am
Bronco also had the luxury of playing in a conference where the G5 teams were familiar to him and the staff.
TheLoneCougar
7/12/19 10:08am
That goes both ways. Teams were more familiar with us too.
D.T. Survivor
7/12/19 10:36am
That's true
TheLoneCougar
7/12/19 11:19am
Coaching staff cohesiveness/experience, player experience, a good QB
SUAVO
7/12/19 9:59am
<< Deleted >>
puntersarepeople
7/12/19 10:04am
Past results are interesting but I expect this year's team is better than the
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:04am
I sure hope so - the status quo may lead to a 4 or 5 win season
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:08am
True but Kalani does have 2 yrs left on his contract so I doubt he'd be let go
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:16am
BYU needs him to succeed but results need to improve on the field
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:26am
To me it comes down to QB play
CaliWG
7/12/19 10:05am
To me it comes down to OL and DL play even more
ManicBlue
7/12/19 10:08am
This. If I were to point to one reason why we've been so mediocre during indy,
Cougar76
7/12/19 10:13am
Agree with both. Given a solid O line QB is critical for both college and Pros.
Refugee
7/12/19 10:21am
Sounds right. We've been below average and are losing to above-average teams.
vagabonder
7/12/19 10:08am
QB Play. 2014 was by far Taysom's best season accuracy wise, which is why
Ash
7/12/19 10:25am
Taysom was 6-2 while Tanner was 5-3 as a starter in these games
BYU Fan
7/12/19 10:31am
Our offense has been below average and coaching
D.T. Survivor
7/12/19 10:39am
Digging for silver linings the last couple yrs will only end with more crap on
Mr. Scoobs
7/12/19 11:20am
RE: BYU vs G5 bowl eligible teams under Kalani Sitake
blu76
7/12/19 12:13pm
There are some teams it’s evident their talent is much greater
D.T. Survivor
7/12/19 12:37pm
RE: BYU vs G5 bowl eligible teams under Kalani Sitake
CougarThug
7/12/19 1:13pm
That's why I don't put too much stock in "P5" & "G5". A good team is a good team
andrewg3
7/12/19 1:14pm
So this season we play 5 good-great G5 teams.
bigbossbyu
7/12/19 1:17pm
I was leaning towards 7-5 as well until I saw how poorly we've done lately
BYU Fan
7/12/19 1:24pm
RE: I was leaning towards 7-5 as well until I saw how poorly we've done lately
hammergm
7/12/19 2:32pm
Except he hasn’t really shown the ability to recruit or develop talent well.
bigbossbyu
7/12/19 3:16pm
I've been thinking about talent
BYU Fan
7/12/19 3:55pm
#extendKalaniandTom
Gerald-DeGroot
7/12/19 1:23pm
RE: BYU vs G5 bowl eligible teams under Kalani Sitake
hammergm
7/12/19 1:59pm
I'm very curious to see what happens with the trajectory this year
BYU Fan
7/12/19 2:15pm
The way Holmoe has set this up the schedule
hammergm
7/12/19 2:40pm
After averaging a 33 finish for over a decade, a 112 finish and a 63 finish last
Mr. Scoobs
7/12/19 2:35pm
Ignorant comment scoobs
hammergm
7/12/19 2:45pm
I'm literally posting data based on actual results.
Mr. Scoobs
7/12/19 3:05pm
Scoobs just comes on here to rip on BYU Football.
PessimisticCB
7/12/19 4:42pm
And this is coming from a guy that has Pessimistic in his name.
PessimisticCB
7/12/19 4:43pm
Bringing facts and data to the discussion shouldn’t be seen as a biased
Mr. Scoobs
7/12/19 4:47pm
Mediocrity is the only result after a terrible team
puntersarepeople
7/12/19 9:49pm
“Let it play out before you make a decision”
Mr. Scoobs
7/12/19 9:59pm
Improvement did happen. It just needs to continue
puntersarepeople
7/12/19 10:41pm
And this is where I disagree.. a 63 finish is still very far away
Mr. Scoobs
7/12/19 10:53pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad