My Account
Sign up, and CougarBoard will remember which categories you want to view.
Sign up
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 19, 2018
10:19
:01
am
Indy Coug
Loquacious Lummox
BYU already "benched" several players between the Cal and Wisconsin games
So they clearly aren't afraid to make the hard decisions. They just don't agree with your assessment of what needs to happen at QB.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Indy Coug
Bio page
Indy Coug
Joined
Dec 20, 2001
Last login
Sep 27, 2024
Total posts
187,999 (10,034 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Imagine a world where Wisconsin hits that FG.
SLC-Warrior
9/19/18 10:17am
No.
jdub
9/19/18 10:18am
Wisconsin makes the field goal, but that doesn't give them the win. An O/T win
spoxjox
9/19/18 10:18am
In that imaginary world, Tanner could have thrown the winning TD pass ...
BluesBrother
9/19/18 10:19am
BYU already "benched" several players between the Cal and Wisconsin games
Indy Coug
9/19/18 10:19am
If we are imagining, then I am imagining that we also beat Cal
Carnac
9/19/18 10:19am
Tanner would then end the game with 4 -5 TDs
Mr. Scoobs
9/19/18 10:20am
Imagine a world where Holker actually makes that catch and we aren't even
P-Boy Squad
9/19/18 10:25am
If Holker caught that pass I still pass on Mangum.
SLC-Warrior
9/19/18 10:29am
I guess if you can prove to me that Wilson, Hall, or Cirtchlow
P-Boy Squad
9/19/18 11:32am
Replied to wrong person, sorry
CougarVeteran
9/19/18 11:54am
Imagine Wilson replaced Mangum in the Wisconsin game
CougarVeteran
9/19/18 11:56am
This is what would have happened
Blue2thebone
9/19/18 2:09pm
I thought he meant Marc Wilson, and as a certified Marc Wilson Fan Club member,
spoxjox
9/19/18 2:14pm
I think that actually means that your opinion of him is set, despite how he play
fattycoug
9/19/18 1:26pm
It is called the last 14 games where Bushman ran the route. I know he was
thecthdox
9/19/18 12:02pm
Can't compare us to Bama. If we had Tagovailoa, he'd be starting right now.
Josef K
9/19/18 10:26am
Not a sure thing, It would depend on how he reads the jet sweep
USMCdad
9/19/18 10:35am
If the defense played worse, we'd want Tanner's head right now.
mudpupper
9/19/18 10:26am
Exactly.
SLC-Warrior
9/19/18 10:30am
We'd want Tanner's head for the O not putting up more than 24 on WISCONSIN?
GOR
9/19/18 11:26am
Remind me how much we scored against Wisconsin last year?
panguitch
9/19/18 11:36am
6 last year. 24 this year. I'll take it.
GOR
9/19/18 12:28pm
We have 2 wins. Just stick with TM for now
Y4LYFE
9/19/18 10:26am
In that world...
BigYfan
9/19/18 10:26am
Instead of re-typing, let me just put this here...
Eddie
9/19/18 10:30am
Go back and watch the game. Tanner won that
Cougar Rage
9/19/18 10:32am
Don't want him benched, but he also had an open guy at the sticks on that play
fulano
9/19/18 10:34am
on the wide side of the field...going away...with a defender playing it short...
MormonThug
9/19/18 11:02am
*in front of the sticks. Likely would have been 4th anyway. High risk/low reward
SUAVO
9/19/18 11:28am
Orrrr maybe a better QB actually completes a pass there for a first down.
SandYFan
9/19/18 10:38am
Orrr a young quarter back throws a pick six. If we were down, Tanner tries to
Cougar Rage
9/19/18 10:48am
Yes hooray our SENIOR QB outperformed a hypothetical 18 year old
SandYFan
9/19/18 10:50am
Glad you are a "backups are always better" kind of guy
SUAVO
9/19/18 11:31am
I'm not, and there's no way you logically got that from my post.
SandYFan
9/19/18 12:12pm
I actually thought he panicked and threw it away to quickly
Hang10
9/19/18 11:27am
I was actually pleased that he DID throw some of those away.
Eddie
9/19/18 11:36am
Too often Wisconsin had our pass plays read and had Tanner rapidly backpedaling
jre85
9/19/18 11:46am
Yep, same. Though he missed wide open back couple times.
MatthiasG
9/19/18 3:01pm
There was a great backup available with different skills for Alabama
Belboz
9/19/18 10:35am
LOL. BYU just upset the #6 team in the nation and you want to bench the QB?!
FrankenCoug
9/19/18 10:37am
Yeah I am not superstitious. Just because we won doesn't mean he played well.
SLC-Warrior
9/19/18 10:45am
I think that is the WHOLE POINT, isn't it?
Eddie
9/19/18 11:00am
This kind of thing is such a waste of time...
Refugee
9/19/18 10:38am
A couple times he threw the ball away instead of taking a sack. Secured the FG!
Mr. Scoobs
9/19/18 10:44am
Runs were working
I'mBatman
9/19/18 11:06am
You're saying that our coaches made a bad decision based on fear?
panguitch
9/19/18 11:18am
Imagine a world where the average football knowledge level on CB was above
Six Foot Seven
9/19/18 11:32am
It would be if you got off
SLC-Warrior
9/19/18 11:56am
RE: It would be if you got off
Six Foot Seven
9/19/18 12:03pm
Calling yourself names won't solve anything.
SLC-Warrior
9/19/18 12:09pm
Wait. You're going with the "I know you are, but what am I" defense?
Eddie
9/19/18 12:51pm
RE: It would be if you got off
GOR
9/19/18 12:29pm
What makes you think our coaches are keeping Tanner as
1CougFan
9/19/18 11:47am
Imagine a world where Columbus doesn't discover America
MajorZeus
9/19/18 1:16pm
...where the whole rainbow of humanity lives in perfect harmony and peace...
spoxjox
9/19/18 2:15pm
RE: Imagine a world where Wisconsin hits that FG.
m0resn0w
9/20/18 3:02pm
I don’t have to bc they didn’t
BYU Grounds
9/21/18 12:01pm
Technically 12 more points, but we get it.
Six Foot Seven
9/21/18 12:48pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad