My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Sep 18, 2018
9:41
:52
am
jdub
Unofficial CB Pollyanna
That play tells me he WILL be a big time player. Yeah, he should have reeled it in, and I think he will in the future.
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
jdub
Bio page
jdub
Joined
May 13, 2004
Last login
Sep 28, 2024
Total posts
79,220 (17,886 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Holker's "catch"
Ham
9/18/18 9:32am
What happened to his arm? It looked like a layer of skin got burned off
Huge Manatee
9/18/18 9:34am
RE: What happened to his arm? It looked like a layer of skin got burned off
cougars8432
9/18/18 9:39am
turf was 120 degrees
1984coug
9/18/18 11:24am
Welcome to fake grass...I have scars on my hips and elbows from playing on it...
whiteninja
9/18/18 2:12pm
I do
BigYfan
9/18/18 9:34am
ha ha
Dillinger
9/18/18 9:34am
I don’t think they would have given it to UW, but if they did,
bluesloth
9/18/18 9:41am
Dropped it
TRUE_BLUE_COUGY
9/18/18 9:34am
I thought the replay was clear he dropped it.
jdub
9/18/18 9:35am
Yes he dropped the ball.
Zoobieman
9/18/18 9:36am
RE: Holker's "catch"
cougars8432
9/18/18 9:38am
Had he not juggled it when it first hit his hand you can make a case that the
Ned Schneebly
9/18/18 9:50am
RE: Had he not juggled it when it first hit his hand you can make a case that
cougars8432
9/18/18 10:18am
I'd recommend going back and watching it again. The ball clearly pops out when
Ned Schneebly
9/18/18 10:34am
RE: I'd recommend going back and watching it again. The ball clearly pops out
Cougar3284
9/18/18 1:21pm
Agree to disagree... but your son is a stud!!! 🙂
Ned Schneebly
9/18/18 3:32pm
RE: Agree to disagree... but your son is a stud!!! 🙂
Cougar3284
9/18/18 3:34pm
Dude, your son is going to be an awesome player at BYU.
Ham
9/18/18 3:49pm
RE: Dude, your son is going to be an awesome player at BYU.
Cougar3284
9/18/18 4:51pm
Yep. He caught it and clearly had control. It looked like he lost control when he was
YardTime
9/18/18 6:40pm
Welcome to CougarBoard. My Advice: Enjoy CougarBoard for entertainment purposes only. 😉
BYU Folsom Fan
9/18/18 6:24pm
A "football move" should be more than just falling to the ground.
Tricky
9/18/18 2:13pm
Honestly people who think it was a catch and fumble don't understand the rule
Adrielle
9/18/18 9:38am
Very clear that he dropped it, ball hit the ground and he never really had control.
BengalCougar
9/18/18 9:39am
Just playing devil's advocate. He had the ball firmly in two hands at one point.
GOR
9/18/18 12:55pm
Does anyone think his little push off was OPI?
Endocoug
9/18/18 9:39am
RE: Does anyone think his little push off was OPI?
cougars8432
9/18/18 9:41am
eh, he'll make that catch. the greatest drop balls like that. they also make
smokymountainrain
9/18/18 9:41am
Dude is a true freshman. He'll catch more of those than he drops over his career
Eddie
9/18/18 9:46am
That play tells me he WILL be a big time player. Yeah, he should have reeled it in, and I think he will in the future.
jdub
9/18/18 9:41am
Coach Chryst thought it was. He was livid at the no call.
TN_Coug
9/18/18 9:42am
As would BYU coaches and fans if roles were reversed. Good no call though.
fulano
9/18/18 9:55am
Signed, BYU fan.
Ktar
9/18/18 1:03pm
Usually not called unless the receiver fully extends his harms.
Freddie Cougar
9/18/18 9:42am
Not enough to be called
TRUE_BLUE_COUGY
9/18/18 9:52am
It seemed kind of necessary to be able to get his hands up to catch the ball. If
BeefNoodleCoug
9/18/18 9:59am
I thought it was OPI, so did chryst....
idacoug
9/18/18 12:41pm
Collie made a living in college (figuratively:) off of 'push offs' like that...
RICoug
9/18/18 2:55pm
All the great receivers use that technique. Austin Collie was the best!
BYU Folsom Fan
9/18/18 4:32pm
I’m pretty sure he bumped the ball with his own leg.
PJMort
9/18/18 9:42am
The initial problem is the ball got into his facemask as he was making the catch
fulano
9/18/18 9:56am
Granted...I watched the game on my phone at an airport but that's how it looked.
fulano
9/18/18 9:57am
Yes
SDcookie
9/18/18 9:43am
Those that think he caught it need to watch it in real speed and not just freeze
Ned Schneebly
9/18/18 9:53am
It wasn’t a catch
TunaNoCrust
9/18/18 10:02am
The only thing i think is that we should have hurried and snapped the ball.
ballen
9/18/18 10:03am
Yup. Cal burned us on that the week before but we need to be ready next time
fulano
9/18/18 10:11am
I was saying the same thing. Hurry, run a play. Right away.
Trent
9/18/18 11:27am
I was in the stadium and behind the play. It looked like a catch so i can see
ballen
9/18/18 11:50am
Was thinking the same thing.
Orem58thBall
9/18/18 7:43pm
I don't think it was indisputable, so the call on the field should stand.
HenderCoug
9/18/18 10:15am
Bingo, this is the answer.
Heavily MeDeekated
9/18/18 10:57am
Well, I do see people disputing it, so I guess that makes it indisputable...
BYUCLA
9/18/18 11:05am
Yes 100%
BigYfan
9/18/18 11:18am
I would agree with this. I wasn't entirely sold that he didn't have control
archie
9/18/18 11:51am
This is my take on it as well
Big Papi
9/18/18 2:07pm
They had an angle they showed on TV that made it pretty obvious...
Eddie
9/18/18 3:07pm
And that may be. I was in the stadium, so I only saw what they showed on
Big Papi
9/18/18 9:52pm
I was pretty optimistic it would stand as a catch for the first 2-3 replays...
Eddie
9/19/18 8:35am
It was indisputable. I dont think there is any reasonable interpretation
LifeLongLakerFan
9/18/18 5:28pm
Dropped it imo
MatthiasG
9/18/18 10:52am
It was called a catch, it could go either way. It was not conclusive that
Pretorian
9/18/18 11:14am
He did take 2 steps with 2 hands on the ball, so I could see why some think that
Y4LYFE
9/18/18 11:16am
Here's the rule: (the clinchers are in first and third sentences of Article 3(b)
boscatar
9/18/18 12:09pm
That's the way it looked on slow-mo...but full speed prob looked like he dropped
zerome4sooners
9/18/18 12:22pm
I know he didn't catch it and he should have... but I like Holker a lot.
Heath Squashwell
9/18/18 12:37pm
I watched the replay numerous times. It looked to me like Holker caught the
Chuckie2304
9/18/18 1:34pm
if you watch the slomo in slomo, he had control for a very long time
Hill4Heisman
9/18/18 2:09pm
If you watch it in real time, he didn't have control for very long at all. If you read the rules, as linked above,
jdub
9/18/18 2:12pm
You serious, Clark?
Mr Blue
9/18/18 3:15pm
Sure am, Zoey. Just as serious as all the other people on this thread who agree with me, the replay officials
jdub
9/18/18 3:21pm
So you didnt catch at all that he was joking? "watching the slomo in slomo"
Mr Blue
9/19/18 8:26am
Wasn’t a catch.
Gerald-DeGroot
9/18/18 2:27pm
Obvious incompletion. I was surprised they spent so long on the review.
The Chelsea Dagger
9/18/18 2:58pm
It's actually evident that he did catch the ball, then coughed it up. I also
RebelScum
9/18/18 5:47pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad