My Account
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Aug 23, 2017
11:07
:33
am
Y4LYFE
All-American
link?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
Y4LYFE
Bio page
Y4LYFE
Joined
Mar 31, 2011
Last login
Oct 3, 2019
Total posts
9,412 (2 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Article: Patrick Kinahan: Rules should force BYU to let Bernard leave without restriction
View
[KSL.com]
Patrick Kinahan, KSL.com Contributor
8/23/17 10:27am
We have all agreed to let you leave without restriction PK
cougarmanguy
8/23/17 10:28am
Do we even know if FB has asked for a release? Isn't he still thinking it over-- despite what his bro says.
soupie
8/23/17 10:29am
no indication from any reliable source that it is true. Tuiaki withdrew his
cougarmanguy
8/23/17 10:30am
link?
Y4LYFE
8/23/17 11:07am
link to what? Tuiaki? It was discussed all day yesterda
cougarmanguy
8/23/17 11:15am
I get that PK is buddies with KW and all...
Eddie
8/23/17 10:32am
It's also pressing into ncaa ethically gray area
cougarmanguy
8/23/17 10:33am
Rules should force Patrick Kinahan to leave the state of Utah.
LiveY'r
8/23/17 10:33am
PK has the names wrong. The headline is more apt for the Tukuafua story.
84 Grad
8/23/17 10:35am
Definitely applies. It fits both situations.
BustinCoveys
8/23/17 10:58am
Does it fit the Bernard case? Is BYU withholding his transfer?
84 Grad
8/23/17 11:02am
Nobody knows.
BustinCoveys
8/23/17 11:07am
You should be able to restrict from teams on schedule over remaining eligiblity
Honor Code
8/23/17 10:40am
If you never attended the school or practice, you should be unrestricted (Joe T)
Honor Code
8/23/17 10:41am
There is even a Kyle Whittingham quote at the end that says just that
BrutustheBrash
8/23/17 10:50am
This headline is ridiculous. The article is just an argument that athletes
JustKeyrock
8/23/17 10:40am
PK writes an ethically bankrupt article. He is not forthcoming about the
darkcoug
8/23/17 10:42am
I agree with him. What's everyone's problem?
SoCalCoug
8/23/17 10:53am
I've learned that most don't care about individuals, only institutions.
thebruce
8/23/17 10:58am
Why can't both be protected?
cougfromcali
8/23/17 11:15am
Programs should have a right to kick someone out
thebruce
8/23/17 11:18am
Why should players have a right to transfer without penalty if it could...
cougfromcali
8/23/17 11:26am
Are you prohibited from receiving money from a 3rd party?
thebruce
8/23/17 11:44am
Hahaha, really? Only like every time. Non-competes and/or buyout penalties are
cougfromcali
8/23/17 11:52am
So wait, you can't take money if you sell some shoes or accept gifts?
thebruce
8/23/17 11:58am
I'm not talking about a competitor. I'm talking about a booster.
thebruce
8/23/17 11:59am
Sure, that's not all that uncommon either, but it depends on the job, of course.
cougfromcali
8/23/17 12:13pm
My point is you are acting like a student athlete is comparable to regular jobs
thebruce
8/23/17 12:24pm
Nobody forces them to sign their contracts. In fact, most students would give...
cougfromcali
8/23/17 1:40pm
Again, you are proving you care about institutions more than individuals.
thebruce
8/23/17 1:43pm
No, I really don't, I just care that contracts which benefit BOTH are honored.
cougfromcali
8/23/17 1:47pm
Yes, and I'm saying the contracts aren't fair to both.
thebruce
8/23/17 1:51pm
So, let me get this straight -- you're proposing that rival school boosters...
cougfromcali
8/23/17 1:59pm
RE: So, let me get this straight -- you're proposing that rival school
lstarr
8/23/17 2:06pm
Whoa ... where did you come from in this discussion?
ManicBlue
8/23/17 2:11pm
No I'm not talking about rivals at all.
thebruce
8/23/17 2:09pm
So you're not talking about FB at all then? Just trying to get your argument
ManicBlue
8/23/17 2:13pm
Is this a serious question?
cougfromcali
8/23/17 11:16am
Two big problems I see:
LiveY'r
8/23/17 11:44am
Based on all the KW quotes, there's nothing justifying the headline's assertion.
Accipiter
8/23/17 10:56am
Headlines are written by the copy desk, not the writer of the article. Seems they have
soupie
8/23/17 10:58am
Got it. PK basically wrote the headline in the first paragraph though, so in
Accipiter
8/23/17 11:59am
Yep, that's basically what they go off. Read the lead (1st paragraph or so) and write the headline.
soupie
8/23/17 12:06pm
He said the same exact thing many on here have said for days.
BustinCoveys
8/23/17 10:57am
Wonder why there was no article aimed at USU, this is clearly not an issue here
Jericho
8/23/17 10:58am
KSL, you shouldnt bother coming here. I never click on a PK garbarticle
Y4LYFE
8/23/17 11:07am
Love how the BYU player who hasn't announced anything is chosen for this article
zerome4sooners
8/23/17 11:34am
PK is a HACK!
DirkSpiderS
8/23/17 11:42am
If coaches can leave (they have penalties paid by the new school), then athletes
TailgateU
8/23/17 11:44am
Often coaches have non-competes too. Look at Bielema's contract at Arkansas...
cougfromcali
8/23/17 11:58am
Things have sure been quiet about Bernard
bluegato
8/23/17 12:19pm
That would be devastating for Bernard. He would be redshirting here but wouldn't
The Lone Star Cougar
8/23/17 12:24pm
IIRC, he could enroll at utah before Sept 1st in order to be eligible but can't
ManicBlue
8/23/17 2:05pm
He can enroll and even practice but he cannot get on schollie for a year
Jericho
8/23/17 2:11pm
PK is a tool. It's funny that the article is about BYU's handling of FB but the
ManicBlue
8/23/17 1:19pm
What a complete idiot. Coaches have contracts the same as players
youngbuck
8/23/17 1:30pm
RE: What a complete idiot. Coaches have contracts the same as players
lstarr
8/23/17 1:43pm
It's actually becoming more common for coaches to have non-competes as well.
cougfromcali
8/23/17 1:48pm
I didn't read his article the San
youngbuck
8/23/17 1:50pm
I didn't read his article the same way, missed the argument you made.
youngbuck
8/23/17 1:52pm
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad