when I did listen it was wall to wall coverage of utah---which is fine. That just doesn't interest me. They also had a bit of an uppity attitude about Utah over BYU that came across as homer bias---which again, is fine if only one of the two were that way.
The problem with that show is that there was no way they were ever going to be able to appeal to both BYU and Utah fans. Both of them are hardcore Utah guys. There is nothing wrong with having one of your hosts be that way---but they would have been better off with a red/blue show or even pairing gunther with an outsider that is neutral (kevin graham, monty, etc)
You could clearly tell that they enjoyed talking Utah far more than BYU---which is totally understandable given their allegiances....it just limited their ratings.