My Account
Invalid message
Report problem with this ad
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Oct 21, 2016
10:32
:02
am
thebruce
Starter
It's weird, you and I agree on almost everything these days
When did that happen?
Start a related thread
Start a related poll
Reply via Boardmail
Report problem with this ad
thebruce
New username
JoeExotic
Bio page
thebruce
Joined
Jul 19, 2014
Last login
Mar 27, 2020
Total posts
0 (0 FO)
Report problem with this ad
Messages
Author
Time
Do you guys even remember the Michigan game? The Mizzou game? The SJSU game?
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:32am
Sad we'll never be able to find out
franklyvulgar
10/21/16 1:33am
Where's he going next year?
SoCalCoug
10/21/16 1:38am
<< Deleted >>
Abe Froman
10/21/16 10:56am
This argument has been made a million times. Tanner was a freshman, Taysom is
crazY
10/21/16 1:34am
And you field the best player for 2016. That's taysom, like it or not.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:35am
How do you know?
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:37am
The same way you do.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:37am
I know what you are but what am I
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:38am
What are you seeing that the coaches aren't?
SoCalCoug
10/21/16 1:39am
4th and 19
thebruce
10/21/16 11:20am
how do you know? look, I have hoped they put in Tanner but I don't work with the
fattycoug
10/21/16 1:39am
RE: And you field the best player for 2016. That's taysom, like it or not.
crazY
10/21/16 1:38am
That's what the coaches believe. They see tanner practice every week.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:42am
YOU SHOUDLNT CARE WHAT HE DOES IN PRACTICE
Shteve
10/21/16 1:45am
Name a D1 program that pulled their starter after a 1 point loss to a top 15
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 1:46am
or show where the majority of the teams that replace their QB midseason are
fattycoug
10/21/16 1:48am
Both very bad ideas as far as coming to conclusions off of them.
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 1:57am
Agreed. Which is why if something isn't working
Shteve
10/21/16 2:03am
Joe Montana 1977 National Championship Team
Shteve
10/21/16 2:01am
majority
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:03am
what good does playing Taysom have for this program?
Shteve
10/21/16 2:07am
You should ask that at Monday's coordinator's corner.
SCcoug
10/21/16 2:10am
if it's so obviously the wrong call to play taysom. then you have to say the
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:12am
Yes it appears many in this thread are saying just that.
SCcoug
10/21/16 2:14am
some are also saying that they aren't replacing him because they are afraid
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:15am
I shouldn't be on here after losses. Too many emotional knuckleheads.
SCcoug
10/21/16 2:16am
Wait, what? To question decisions of coaches is to call them outright idiots?
marklar39
10/21/16 2:34am
Now that you mention it. How do explain Fake punt from own endzone 4th and 19???
Osteotome
10/21/16 10:49am
Ty Detmer comes to mind.
crazY
10/21/16 2:05am
correct me if I am wrong, and I could very well be, but didn't he come in becaus
fattycoug
10/21/16 2:13am
You're correct. Bad memory on my part.
crazY
10/21/16 2:16am
Name a D1 team this year whose defense provided them 5 TOs
Shteve
10/21/16 2:09am
Only 3 of those to's resulted in the offense coming on the field. So 1 of 3.
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 2:10am
Fair point. With a blocked field goal and return to near mid field
Shteve
10/21/16 2:17am
LOL, and plz remind us all how much Taysom had to do with being that close? lol
Ash
10/21/16 11:12am
I honestly believe Tanner gets sacked 8+ times, and throws at least one INT
Dissenter
10/22/16 1:22am
??? Based on . . . ? Tea leaves? Because we haven't seen him in this offense.
Michicoug
10/22/16 7:51am
I thought Taysom was a 5th year senior. First game of college career was 2012. No previous redshirt other than the medic
MacGyver
10/21/16 10:27am
If only there were some way to prove he could play well against Boise...
Disco LaFleur
10/21/16 1:35am
17-28, 309 yards, 2 TD/2 INT.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:38am
Cool, calm, and collected in the end.
Disco LaFleur
10/21/16 1:39am
And a W. In his second game ever.
bluesloth
10/21/16 1:39am
21-42, 187 yards, 0 TD/0 INT
crazY
10/21/16 1:42am
Taysom also ran for a TD.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:43am
1 inch dives ftw
franklyvulgar
10/21/16 1:44am
Because the 30 yard strike to MJ came up 1/2 yard short.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:45am
You're squarely for Taysom at quarterback. Fine. That's cool. But when things
Disco LaFleur
10/21/16 1:53am
Tanner still had twice as many points as Taysom did.
crazY
10/21/16 1:47am
He also had Houk, Matthews, and Blackmon.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:49am
Yet none of them had touchdowns that game. Juergens had both touchdowns.
crazY
10/21/16 1:54am
Right.
flyusaf
10/21/16 3:15am
So what's your argument?
crazY
10/21/16 8:59am
Better receivers in 2015.
flyusaf
10/21/16 9:51am
Better qb too
thebruce
10/21/16 9:59am
Yet 3 of the top 6 receivers are back.
crazY
10/21/16 10:14am
And let's be real, Jonah Trinnaman is as good as blackmon
thebruce
10/21/16 10:20am
Remember he was limited that game. Hamstring injury
Orange4Life
10/21/16 6:21am
I'd take that with our run game in a heartbeat.
macaroni
10/21/16 7:47am
So Taysom isn't at fault because the problem is the team but Tanner is fully
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:36am
Didn't say that.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:38am
No. It's a team game. Blame goes around.
SCcoug
10/21/16 1:38am
Exactly.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:39am
The player who touches the ball every play can significantly affect the game.
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:39am
You're right. Cougarrrs is wrong. I love Taysom, but he's dropped hard...
marklar39
10/21/16 1:40am
My problem is that when an offense consistently lacks production, the answer in MOST cases at most schools is to
ChinaFan
10/21/16 1:41am
Problem is they haven't lacked until today. Against a top 15 team at their place
Cougarrrs
10/21/16 2:15am
You must have been watching a different BYU then than the rest of us -
OGSuperfan
10/21/16 2:21am
Right Taysom's been terrific against everyone else which is why the passing
Michicoug
10/21/16 7:43am
Agreed. He was thrown into the fire and struggled often, in a very different
BigD Coug
10/21/16 1:41am
Don't forget Tanners post-mish rust and hamstring injury
Run-DMT
10/21/16 1:44am
Yeah he played well given the situation he was in.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:46am
He's the best freshman QB BYU has EVER had
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:47am
You just can't really say that. Everyone has got to stop using
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 1:45am
We shouldn't use the only evidence we have? That would be weird.
flyusaf
10/21/16 1:48am
He is literally the best freshman QB ever at BYU. Of course he will improve in a
HuskerCoug
10/21/16 1:49am
Uh... Remember when Jake Heaps was literally the best freshman qb BYU ever had?
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 9:33am
Jake Heaps was not the best freshman QB BYU has ever had. Tanner holds records.
crazY
10/21/16 9:49am
The records that Heaps had before Tanner broke them you mean?
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 3:40pm
Also not arguing that Tanner isn't/won't progress or that he should or shouldn't
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 3:44pm
Heaps did do well for a freshman. But Tanner came in and obliterated Heaps' records.
indocoug
10/21/16 11:13am
BYUFootballisBack
10/21/16 3:39pm
We shouldn't assume that players stay exactly the same year after year.
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 1:53am
No, we analyze it in CONTEXT.
macaroni
10/21/16 7:49am
Our offense in the past two games put up 14 and 13 points, respectively. 14 and 13! Our d scored more last night! And
macaroni
10/21/16 7:54am
No but MAYBE he would IMPROVE with reps for NEXT year. Taysom ISN'T IMPROVING
Osteotome
10/21/16 10:55am
It's weird, you and I agree on almost everything these days
thebruce
10/21/16 10:32am
I don't think we ever disagreed on a ton of stuff.
southernfriedcougar
10/21/16 2:10pm
You just literally listed the #2, 3, and 6 ranked pass Ds in college football
thebruce
10/21/16 4:15am
Uconn and Utah state both had top 18 pass D last year.
thebruce
10/21/16 4:17am
Starting Tanner could have been about 2017 not just 2016
Cougstreak
10/21/16 5:23am
The fact that they didn't pull Taysom in this game pretty much guarantees
jensen46
10/21/16 6:18am
Because Tanner would obviously be exactly the same as last year and have not
Michicoug
10/21/16 7:39am
I think your memory is poor.
macaroni
10/21/16 7:47am
How so?
flyusaf
10/21/16 9:53am
TRUE FRESHMAN JUST OFF HIS MISSION. Yes I'm yelling. This is nearly the
TheLoneCougar
10/21/16 8:08am
Do you guys realize Tanner was passing to Matthews, Blackmon & Houk?
cougar_chick1
10/21/16 8:42am
AND had no Jamaal.
Michicoug
10/21/16 8:49am
When you have crap receivers trying to catch from a crappy QB the problem is
thebruce
10/21/16 8:51am
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Excellent Points
Osteotome
10/21/16 10:59am
The underlying assumption here is that Tanner is exactly the same as he was
Frank Castiglione
10/21/16 9:40am
Taysom taking the sack with 22 seconds left was probably the toughest thing to see.
indocoug
10/21/16 10:19am
He pulled the ball down to run but ran right into the teeth of the awaiting D
Osteotome
10/21/16 11:00am
PREACH
doctorthunderpants
10/21/16 10:24am
RE: Do you guys even remember the Michigan game? The Mizzou game? The SJSU game?
HowardH
10/21/16 11:04am
Who was his RB last year?
Ash
10/21/16 11:08am
8 yard Carter
thebruce
10/21/16 11:17am
Somehow he managed to get 37 carries lol
thebruce
10/21/16 11:19am
He trailed in the 2nd half to UConn and Cincy....
jsjohnson1278
10/21/16 12:28pm
Top 25 pass defenses last year.. go look
CarolinaCoug
10/22/16 9:13am
RE: Do you guys even remember the Michigan game? The Mizzou game? The SJSU game?
Bullrider
10/21/16 1:19pm
The backup QB is always the most popular player on the team.
Wear Blue
10/22/16 11:22am
Only on teams with a QB not getting it done
thebruce
10/22/16 11:29am
You're a hopeless coachbot.
Ash
10/22/16 11:32am
And you are hopeless.
Wear Blue
10/23/16 1:59am
We are 4-4 with awful QB play.
Shteve
10/22/16 11:39am
Report problem with this ad
Posting on CougarBoard
In order to post, you will need to either
sign up
or
log in
.
Report problem with this ad