But seeing how that list of four spans 11 years (2005 - 2016), that's not a lot to be proud of.
Here's a list of Polys for the class of 2016 and 2017. This is a quick list thrown together but as you can see, not a lot of them have BYU on their radar. These are 4 and 5 star athletes, ones typically the Y doesn't sign.
c/o 2016
mique juarez 5* - ucla
devin asiasi - michigan
boss tagaloa - ucla
lokeni toailoa - ucla
simi fehoko - stanford (in state kid)
michael eletise - arizona
maxs tupai - utah (in state kid)
vavae malepeai - usc
c/o 2017
aj epenesea 5* - committed to iowa
tua tagovailoa - comitted to alabama
jay tufele - in state kid w/ byu offer
chaz ah you - in state kid w/ byu offer
chuck filiaga - father lives in utah
sione heimuli-lund - committed to stanford
marlon tuipulotu - commited to UW
langi tuifua - in state committed oregon
josh falo - no byu offer
isaiah pola-mao - byu offer
juliano falaniko - committed to usc
tayler katoa - byu offer
popo aumavae - no byu offer
isaac slade-matautia - no byu offer