In most years either one of these guys could win the Heisman. Jeanty looks like Barry Sanders and is putting up Barry Sanders type numbers
He's nearly on pace for the total yards and is actually ahead of pace to break Sanders' TD record. Hard to not give him the Heisman if he does that.

On the other hand, you've got Travis Hunter absolutely balling out on both sides of the ball, like absolutely nobody has done before. He's got two INTs, a forced fumble, and multiple pass break ups. All while playing nearly every down as on offense as well, where he'll likely finish with over 1,500 yards and 12+ TDs.
Nobody in the modern era has done anything like that.

I'll be happy to enjoy watching these guys play out the rest of the season and see what happens, but both of these guys are extremely rare talents and will likely each be more than deserving.