I didn't include Sagarin since he no longer publishes his Elo rankings which is what BCS used. These rankings are all based off record vs SOS and would be "resume-based" rankings.

1. Oregon
T2. BYU
T2. Penn St
4. Miami FL
5. Kansas St
T6. Iowa St
T6. Georgia
8. Texas
9. Pittsburgh
10. Ohio St
11. Texas A&M
12. Indiana
13. Alabama
14. Notre Dame
15. Boise St
16. SMU
17. Tennessee
18. LSU
19. Clemson
20. Washington St
21. Illinois
22. Colorado
23. Ole Miss
T24. Army
T24. Missouri

Here is what the playoff would look like if based off this.

ROSE
1. Oregon
8. Texas vs 9. Pittsburgh

SUGAR
4. Georgia
5. Penn St vs 12. Boise St

FIESTA
2. BYU
7. Iowa St vs 10. Ohio St

PEACH
3. Miami FL
6. Kansas St vs 11. Texas A&M