The rivalry between BYU and the University of Utah is one of the most intense in college sports, often transcending the typical on-field competition and entering the realm of deep cultural and religious divides. Historically, BYU represents a school founded by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS), with its student body, traditions, and culture closely tied to Mormonism. In contrast, the University of Utah’s program and fanbase, while also largely based in Utah, often identify themselves as a counterpoint to BYU, creating a rivalry that has sometimes taken on anti-LDS tones.

Over the years, this rivalry has become more than just about sports. Utah fans have been known to openly mock LDS beliefs and practices, sometimes targeting sacred LDS symbols in disrespectful ways. Instances of fans or players mimicking LDS practices—like using sacrament trays for alcohol, pretending to perform “laying on of hands,” or mocking baptisms—highlight an uncomfortable trend that goes beyond traditional rivalry. This often fuels a divide that makes it clear that, for some, animosity toward BYU may be tied to animosity toward the LDS Church itself.

More troubling, however, is the culture within the University of Utah’s football program itself. Head coach Kyle Whittingham has come under fire for questionable behavior, including a comment toward a female sideline reporter about her “nice leather pants,” which many saw as inappropriate and unprofessional especially for a married man and community leader. The program has also faced darker issues off the field, with multiple players losing their lives to gun violence—a tragedy that suggests an underlying cultural issue that prioritizes winning over fostering a safe environment. Additionally, defensive coordinator Morgan Scalley’s history of racially insensitive remarks during recruitment raises serious questions about inclusivity within the team culture. Some allege that this "win at all costs" mentality has even bled into the misuse of NIL money, with funds reportedly going to players whose performance doesn’t match the investment.

Then there are the more outrageous aspects of the rivalry that sometimes play out during game days, including reports of Utah fans engaging in crude behavior [west concourse defecation issues], punching pregnant women and accosting elderly BYU fans. Incidents like these reinforce the perception that Utah’s fan culture lacks respect for their rivals, with mockery of LDS individuals and their beliefs as a frequent theme.

This rivalry is undeniably charged, but while healthy competition can strengthen both teams, it seems that a win-at-all-costs mindset has taken hold at Utah, sometimes at the expense of respect and sportsmanship. The contrast with BYU, which strives for a values-based approach to sports and culture, only heightens the divide between these two programs.