POLL: Would Baylor Romney have won the job over Retzlaff?

Sign up, and you'll be able to ignore users whose posts you don't want to see. Sign up

Report problem with this ad

Sep 13, 2024
2:50:01am

Cougs4Lfe Playmaker

POLL: Would Baylor Romney have won the job over Retzlaff?

Report problem with this ad

Cougs4Lfe

Bio page: Cougs4Lfe
Joined: Dec 31, 2020
Last login: Sep 19, 2024
Total posts: 3,061 (6 FO)

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

POLL: Would Baylor Romney have won the job over Retzlaff?

Cougs4Lfe

Sep 13, 2:50am

Without a doubt.

Sep 13, 4:01am

Yes, as would maybe every multi game starter going back decades. Heaps, Nelson, later Mangum, Critchlow, Engemann etc.

byuTX

Sep 13, 5:53am

You lost me at Critchlow

cajuncoug

Sep 13, 6:25am

I was grabbing names at random. But IIRC Critchlow had better numbers than JR, which admittedly isn’t hard at all

byuTX

Sep 13, 6:28am

Agree on all points except I’ve seen plenty of QBs play worse than injured Riley

CougarScrub

Sep 13, 6:36am

Please, watch the 7-6 Boise State game, and name such a performance

cajuncoug

Sep 13, 6:38am

Mangum, 1st quarter Las Vegas Bowl, 2015.

OrsoNero

Sep 13, 7:20am

Critchlow is the only QB I can think of in the history of BYU that I may give

Tuskaloosa Cougar

Sep 13, 7:49am

Not sure. We will have to check the film

byuTX

Sep 13, 9:07am

maybe for a play until he got another concussion

kaladin58

Sep 13, 6:16am

<< Deleted >>

mokelembembe

Sep 13, 6:56am

<< Deleted >>

mokelembembe

Sep 13, 6:58am

And so would Hall, Wilson, Beck, Hill, Detmer, Young, McMahon, Wilson

2FarGone

Sep 13, 7:16am

Serious Clark

44C

Sep 13, 7:31am

No. Retzlaff has a much better arm. It's turnovers that are causing

gopman

Sep 13, 8:01am

No because Arod never trusts anyone already in the program and doesn’t develop.

blueaussie

Sep 13, 8:03am

Romney pushed Hall for the starting job, so he definitely would beat out Jake

Mabuhay Coug

Sep 13, 9:03am

I think it is very likely. He ran the O well.

ImuaKahuku

Sep 13, 9:23am

baylor romney would just read the defense and throw the ball

lukeskywalker

Sep 13, 10:01am

Report problem with this ad

Posting on CougarBoard

In order to post, you will need to either sign up or log in.

Report problem with this ad