Page 1 - CougarBoard

Invalid message

Report problem with this ad

Messages

Author

Time

Mark Harlan better hope Utah retains him as AD, because he'll never be hired at

Dangerous

12:56pm

This is how our current winning streak (9) compares to previous streaks:

Norge Coug

12:56pm

After watching this and letting all of the post game actions sink in, Utah is dang lucky the fine was only 40K

GangstaLean All-American

12:56pm

BYU should consider this on their next trick play adventures…

CougarGuy84

12:56pm

Looking for 4 tickets to the AZ St. game

ProvoProwler

12:56pm

Why do BYU fans need to keep rallying to charitable causes after playing utah?

yorksama

12:55pm

What's the best way to get GOOD seats to a BYU Big 12 basketball game?

RdF3 Inactive user

12:55pm

Sell your first born.

CougarGuy84

12:56pm

The Athletic predicts BYU will lose. Loving the lack of respect for motivation!

runnincoug

12:49pm

Something that has been bugging me about the Utah game..

SLIVER

12:48pm

I've had that thought but I think there was another safety who had Ropati

BYU Fan

12:49pm

I don't think so. Watch the replay I put in the OP. One safety over the top and

SLIVER

12:54pm

I could be wrong - that would have been epic!

BYU Fan

12:56pm

Would’ve been very similar to Luke Staleys TD to beat Utah

Hang10

12:49pm

Yes, but with a Taysom-esque hurdle of TWO Utes!

SLIVER

12:52pm

Inches- looks more like a foot or two.

byusage

12:54pm

... But I wouldn't want Utah to get the ball with a minute to spare...

The Dark Knight

12:55pm

With 2 TOs.

foofcoug

12:57pm

Provided BYU holds onto the lead after he scores. How it ended was more certain.

foofcoug

12:56pm

Anyone wanting to sell (2) tickets to tomorrows basketball game vs Idaho?

Borg

12:47pm

The game is Saturday.

Cougar Jazz Fan

12:51pm

I have 2 very high up chair seats I could send your way. Send me a BM.

Niiineteeen84

12:52pm

Joel Klatt walking back his opinion about the holding. About 19:51.

LSUcougar92

12:44pm

Love it when people can gain perspective with additional information. Harlan,

Captain Stubing

12:48pm

Says different angles change his mind

Hawk Talons

12:48pm

I think he's a good in game announcer. But he's a total homer outside the game.

Adwight

12:48pm

Wonder if Furlong and Bartle will post that snippet since they posted his

Dangerous

12:55pm

POLL: Regarding this Saturday's Rubble in the Rockies rivalry game, what would you most like to see?

NOCAL_YFAN

12:43pm

ESPN projects Egor to go #7 in the draft to the Spurs… Egor + Wemby = Scary

byuchocolatemilk

12:43pm

Please let it be so

CSoul

12:44pm

yeah, he’d enable a Wemy dunk fest with has gravity driving the ball to the basket

BeyondTheMark

12:44pm

UHC won this game 4-1

CougarCanuck76

12:42pm

How many games this year (excluding FCS teams) do you think Kalani could have legitimately run up the score

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

12:41pm

Just UCF.

Benfica1

12:45pm

Definitely Wyoming (14+) and possibly UCF and Kansas State (7+)

BYU Fan

12:50pm

I don't know about RUTS per se, but it seems opportunities to improve the MOV

ldssdl

12:55pm

Nice write up on BYU’s defense by ESPN

UNLVcougar

12:40pm

Here's why the Unsportsmanlike penalty on Harlan would not have negated a TD:

momowagon

12:39pm

I don't think that's true if you are on the field of play. Are you saying if a

cougarfann888

12:41pm

If the coach tackled a defender, that would be affecting the play and it would

SoCalCoug

12:43pm

What is the definition of "affecting the play"?

SUAVO

12:47pm

Judgement call by the ref. This ref called it as unsportsmanlike.

momowagon

12:47pm

That's my paraphrase of the principle. I'm not sure what the exact wording is,

SoCalCoug

12:48pm

Hopefully the ref wouldn't call that as unsportsmanlike. That would be another

momowagon

12:45pm

Is that the NCAA rules? It's not a TD in college

stansburycoug

12:42pm

Wasn't there a Steelers coach who tripped a player from the sideline a few years ago?

Skeptical Optimist

12:45pm

There are several different application to dead ball in college

stansburycoug

12:49pm

Tomlin was in the way on the sideline, but didn't touch him

steelerguy99

12:52pm

THis lines up with the rule. The RB in this example is not a non-player. Harlan

momowagon

12:47pm

Harlan and Whit should have been out blocking and impeding would be tacklers ?

stansburycoug

12:50pm

That would have been a different penalty than "Unsportsmanlike conduct".

momowagon

12:53pm

? what penalty would that be? I've reffed up to HS, I'm curious what it is?

stansburycoug

12:55pm

What if he was out there blocking? That doesn't make sense.

GfB

12:42pm

But it does. If he blocked a player involved in the play, that would negate the

SoCalCoug

12:44pm

Well in that case his mere physical presence on the field affects that play. Even as just a distraction.

GfB

12:46pm

That is not the rule.

SoCalCoug

12:46pm

It would be a different penalty than just "Unsportsmanlike Conduct"

SoCalCoug

12:47pm

How do you define "involved" in the play? Was Harlan not involved?

LegitCoug

12:47pm

You could argue that, but you would lose.

SoCalCoug

12:47pm

Huh. Well, kind of a fun thought experiment anyway.

LegitCoug

12:48pm

The Ref who made the call said unsportsmanlike conduct, not something else.

momowagon

12:49pm

Interesting. If that's the case...

LegitCoug

12:44pm

Well I would expect penalties outside of the game for that, IE lifetime bans for

Stopper6700

12:46pm

Because if they interrupt the play that's a different penalty. The ref called

momowagon

12:50pm

That would have been the most Utah way to win

Skeptical Optimist

12:44pm

Taken to an extreme, what if a bunch of students ran onto the field and tackled BYU players to allow a TD by Utah.

KingDave

12:44pm

That would result in negating the play.

SoCalCoug

12:45pm

Yes, because it would be something other than unsportsmanlike.

momowagon

12:51pm

I don't know about that. Do you remember when Utah fans rushed the field during

cougarfan84

12:46pm

That wasn't called as "unsportsmanlike." It was sideline interference. If Harlan

momowagon

12:52pm

So what prevents non-players from disrupting the game?

HuskerFan2

12:46pm

That would be a different penalty, not Unsportsmanlike Conduct.

momowagon

12:54pm

If your on the field you would be considered a player in my opinion.

maYbe

12:52pm

Nice opinion! That's not what the rules say.

momowagon

12:55pm

The rule doesn't define a player.

maYbe

12:56pm

Need a rules expert to weigh in here. An administrator five yards into the field

RalphWiggam

12:53pm

The Ref must have concluded that Harlan didn't effect the play, or he would have

momowagon

12:56pm

How to kill your credibility as a local college sportswriter in a sentence

Bobmarleyjr

12:38pm

he cares about your opinion

Avery

12:39pm

If he knew BYU football he would already know the answer

Bobmarleyjr

12:40pm

Surprising number of replies are saying yes.

SWKTNative

12:40pm

Naive, ignorant BYU fans

ldssdl

12:43pm

Go Buffs

ldssdl

12:40pm

This is the way

Bobmarleyjr

12:40pm

No, but may need to root for them against ISU next game.

PJMort

12:41pm

OK, cheer for ISU to lose anyhow- if they don't lose this week.

PJMort

12:46pm

Hey, Klatt..

JohnnyComeLately

12:41pm

If they were playing ISIS's football team, I would not cheer for the Utes.

momowagon

12:42pm

I cheer for the outcomes that help BYU

BYU Fan

12:44pm

This!

PJMort

12:48pm

RE: How to kill your credibility as a local college sportswriter in a sentence

Zooropa

12:52pm

My observation on the Queens game. This BYU team shows that it can play really good defense when they focus...

PJMort Truly Addicted User

12:37pm

Overreaction imo. We went up 35-5. The game intensity was gone. That happens at every level.

GfB

12:41pm

Not trying to be overdramatic, I think this team is really young and has a bunch to learn. We need our upperclassmen...

PJMort

12:45pm

True to a point, but they had the same gaffes against UC Riverside in a close gm

Projectoor

12:49pm

I don't think that had anything to do with intensity. We're putting in a defense that switches constantly. They're

GfB

12:52pm

From a straight up talent standpoint this team IMO is the most talented team I've ever seen at BYU...

Adrielle

12:45pm

Harlan's rant shows how much hubris he has. This is what caused the implosion

osbooks

12:37pm

Utah's 1st year in the Big 12.

JAGA97

12:35pm

855 tickets still available on BYUtickets.com

whirl

12:33pm

Sell it out Cougar fans!

ldssdl

12:40pm

POLL: What action will the Utah administration take on Harlan?

Cthack1 All-American

12:32pm

RE: POLL: What action will the Utah administration take on Harlan?

SJS

12:33pm

Randall is a Big12/BYU plant, tasked with taking down the Ute program, so

NOCAL_YFAN

12:39pm

Force him to continue leading that pile of crap department. That's a big punishment.

Niiineteeen84

12:40pm

Is anyone else ever amazed at what it takes to beat Utah?

BYU Fan

12:30pm

The luck of the yewts is a real thing, unfortunately. Hopefully though, their

ldssdl

12:33pm

Recruiting: why would anyone want their son play for Utah with the team that

Archaea

12:33pm

It’s the worst game of the year every time we play them

Beggar

12:33pm

IMO, it's all about the trenches. As long as I can remember, Utah has

Yucaterco

12:36pm

It’s hard to blow out teams that thrive in the trenches.

NYCougz

12:51pm

I think this year hinged on us not scoring a td on our opening

bald man

12:40pm

Only against BYU, and maybe USC. Everyone else seems to have it kinda easy.

momowagon

12:41pm

A lot of those Utah teams are better than we give them credit.

NYCougz

12:45pm

2021: Brewer didn't have an awful game. Don't buy into the false uu narrative.

Benfica1

12:54pm

Really interested to see how Utah's big rivalry game this weekend goes

NOCAL_YFAN

12:28pm

that team is drained...they will lose by a lot

Avery

12:30pm

But it would be amazing to see Isaac light things up and

jxncoog

12:35pm

I hope he does!

Avery

12:37pm

They gave everything emotionally and physically last week in their Superbowl. Theyre going to get smoked.

WDaddy

12:35pm

After they got up for "The in-State Game" and still couldn't get it done I don't

OKchief

12:35pm

BYU 6 Road Games This Year, Most SEC = 4, Most Big 10 = 5

MoveTheChains

12:28pm

And an SEC "road" game is usually a short bus ride.

DirtyWater

12:31pm

I haven't looked at any of their schedules, but with their geography, I doubt any SEC team has to got TO TX, A&M, AK, MO

ChinaFan

12:42pm

A ride on the short bus?

CopperLix

12:42pm

Of course not. the SEC and B10 can do no wrong.

ldssdl

12:31pm

Indiana has left the state of IN exactly twice this year to play football. They only have 1 more out of state game

BYUMizzou

12:33pm

Tbh, moving forward, BYU needs to do more of this. No major OOC travel.

ldssdl

12:34pm

Turns out we have 2 paths to clinch a CCG appearance this week, if BYU wins and

BYUFootballisBack

12:26pm

Of course this assumes a Byu win against KU

kC Cougar

12:56pm

Alright, is this a 3rd brother? Top recruit in Utah Next year.

cougaman

12:24pm

Next year's class could be legit. Potential for 3+ top 50 players

spidercoug

12:26pm

It is, says right in the Scouting Report in that link, their Dad played at Utah

BYUFootballisBack

12:27pm

If BYU was losing by 4 instead of 2 at the end of the Utah game. I am very

bluehawaiian

12:22pm

Since we won by less than one score, it is actually counted as a loss

willkie40

12:24pm

They forced BYU to get held and have a last-minute drive. It's not really a loss

vagabonder

12:28pm

I’m starting to think that it might not be possible for this team to lose

zuko

12:26pm

Sorry yall, we may lose Saturday and it will be my fault. So far this season I

indocoug

12:19pm

What’s that, indocoug? Your stomach is really starting to hurt? Oh no!

DieHarder

12:21pm

RE: Sorry yall, we may lose Saturday and it will be my fault. So far this season I

cheezedawg

12:21pm

If we lose, we're hunting you and your in-laws down.

2FarGone

12:21pm

I am bringing my son with me to the game. We have not lost a game with my son

dallasbyu

12:21pm

I'm similar. When me and my son go by ourselves, it's always an insane win.

CougarTwins

12:28pm

Thank you for your sacrifice. My wife is also undefeated at BYU games. She is

indocoug

12:48pm

Can't you start a political argument with your SIL and get banned?

JAGA97

12:21pm

RE: Sorry yall, we may lose Saturday and it will be my fault. So far this season

ldssdl

12:22pm

Cancel it out by wearing the same clothes as you did during while watching

SoValleyCOUG

12:24pm

That is what I did for the SMU, OSU, and Yewtah games. I will try to wear that

indocoug

12:50pm

We all know who to blame now if BYU loses on Saturday

BYU Sportz Fan

12:27pm

What you do has no bearing on the outcome

Beggar

12:29pm

My Royal Blue Sailor Coug T-shirt trumps your routine..

Born2Fish

12:31pm

RE: Sorry yall, we may lose Saturday and it will be my fault. So far this season I

jdub

12:35pm

This is so dumb. Superstition plays no role in how BYU does.

HRCougar

12:35pm

RE: This is so dumb. Superstition plays no role in how BYU does.

dallasbyu

12:36pm

Im sure every stadium has garbage fans that make for a terrible experience

CougarCanuck76

12:19pm

This blows my mind. Why are we seeing so much Un sportsmanship from TUN?

MajorZeus

12:21pm

RES doesn't even sell unsportsmanship

vagabonder

12:30pm

I’d like to see all of those tweets about Lavell Edwards Stadium and their fans.

Yukon

12:24pm

The guys I sit by aren't belligerent but the know every play Arod should call

CougarCanuck76

12:27pm

So you are sitting next to CBers then. Please tell us who

spidercoug

12:34pm

Super cool

Borg

12:25pm

A BYU fans experience in RES doesn’t even come close to

DreamerCoug

12:26pm

Talking to my seat neighbor last night. He went to RES for the game. Left 3rd Q

BYUtka

12:27pm

Harassing a kid is next-level idiotic. What kind of adult does that?

BYU Sportz Fan

12:29pm

FWIW, when two teams have season pass efficiency differentials that are about 50 points apart

Indy Coug Loquacious Lummox

12:19pm

That's comforting. Any other statistical disparities stand out to you?

ldssdl

12:21pm

What is the PED for ASU, Houston, and Colorado?

CougarTwins

12:22pm

ASU +22.33 // Houston -0.78 // Colorado +29.20

Spiff

12:28pm

And we are at home. That percentage likely goes up when the better team is

LifeLongLakerFan

12:29pm

Flights for Big XII CCG

cougiewoogie

12:18pm

Set up some alerts on Google Flights. There are a lot of times you can catch a really good deal on mistakes.

AltTabbins

12:20pm

I know he won't read this--but Dave Flemming is one of my favorites on BYU

BYUHawk

12:18pm

I really like Dave. The thing that cracks me up is his voice and how he looks don't seem to match up

jvr7

12:20pm

I get a double dose of him as a Giants fan during baseball season, and I enjoy his sound and commentary. He does a great

RootieBoy

12:27pm

I love his excited voice, especially when his pitch changes middle of a word

D.T. Survivor

12:35pm

How players minutes might go when Hall gets back.(?)...

Undefeated

12:17pm

We won't have a 10 man rotation once games get real. If we do, 2 of those guys

Plato

12:18pm

Yeah I was thinking of the six games that Hall will play in before conference

Undefeated

12:21pm

No way Hall only gets 10 minutes a game

TLCougar

12:18pm

It says he'll get 24 minutes

Undefeated

12:19pm

Sorry, didn't read all of it. 🙂

TLCougar

12:19pm

I’ve tried that exercise a couple of times and it’s really hard. There’s no

DieHarder

12:19pm

I think, in the end, Knell, Baker or Mag won't get many minutes this season.

Mostlyaccurate

12:20pm

Yes, once conference starts, things will change.

Undefeated

12:21pm

honestly, it'll end up being a matchup-dependent rotation

LeonMarek

12:22pm

I think Mag should get minutes due to his D. We’re not that great and he helps

CougGolf

12:25pm

Most teams won't use a 10 man rotation

TLCougar

12:22pm

Looks good

archie

12:25pm

I should give you my POD:)

Undefeated

12:38pm

RES is a great example of environmental efficiency. Its one of the cleanest stadiums in college sports.

AltTabbins I got UtahFootballGM banned.

12:16pm

The trash walks itself out, but sometimes it leaves behind some unclean gifts

NOCAL_YFAN

12:19pm

The stink never leaves. Its soaked into the concrete at this point.

AltTabbins

12:21pm

Two tickets to ASU in Tempe, just want what I paid.

ratherberoping

12:15pm

Looking to buy 2 lower bowl seats to the MBB game vs Idaho.

HuskerFan2

12:14pm

ESPN+
BYU Radio
Live Stats

ESPN
BYU Radio
Live Stats

Top 10 recent

My sister is a teacher in California and had a student at the U for a recruting trip last weekend...

Lisfranc surgery for Rose

What you saw on Saturday is Harlan partially saying the quiet part out loud.

Ouch…a very bad stat for us.

Brayden Keim Update

Hadn't noticed this. But a big indictment against AD Harlan is when Harlan

I haven't seen this video

Jayhawks on BYU

Apparently, there was history between yewtah and the official.

Conversation with a big Notre Dame booster and client just now

Site Statistics

Today

Posts: 3,490
Threads: 406
Visitors: 4,787
Logins: 3,480

Yesterday

Posts: 8,608
Threads: 1,248
Visitors: 6,062
Logins: 3,949

Currently Online

Total: 988
Subscribers: 719
Non-subscribers: 179
Non-login: 90

More statistics

Report problem with this ad